Have a query about your private investments? Irrespective of how easy or advanced, you’ll be able to ask it right here.
- Posts: 16486
- Joined: Fri Apr 10, 2015 12:29 am
Re: Fidleity told me to up stock allocation
Post
by Northern Flicker »
However that’s not what the advisor did. The advisor didn’t open a dialogue about whether or not the AA was what’s finest for the investor’s private circumstance. The advisor made a advice primarily based on market outlook.
- Posts: 32875
- Joined: Tue Feb 27, 2007 7:09 pm
- Location: Miami FL
Re: Fidelity told me to up stock allocation
Post
by Taylor Larimore »
Think about using Vanguard’s Asset-Allocation instrument:
https://retirementplans.vanguard.com/VG … -OX77-OGQQ
Greatest needs.
Taylor
Jack Bogle’s Phrases of Knowledge: “Asset allocation is critically essential; however price is critically essential, too — All different elements pale into insignificance.” “Higher diversification is the final refuge of the scoundrel.” “Select a steadiness of shares and bonds in line with your distinctive circumstances–your funding goal, your time horizon, your degree of consolation with danger, and your monetary assets.” Completely nobody is aware of what the inventory market goes to do tomorrow, not to mention subsequent yr. Nor which sector, type or area will lead and which is able to lag.”
- Posts: 10049
- Joined: Wed Feb 19, 2014 9:11 am
Re: Fidleity told me to up stock allocation
Post
by SmileyFace »
Northern Flicker wrote: ↑Wed Sep 18, 2024 12:36 pmHowever that’s not what the advisor did. The advisor didn’t open a dialogue about whether or not the AA was what’s finest for the investor’s private circumstance. The advisor made a advice primarily based on market outlook.
I do not know if we all know all of the background and data the advisor took into consideration. In the event that they knew the OP had a big pension protecting all bills – that might issue right into a advice of accelerating inventory allocation.
In any case – I agree – no cause to maneuver to Vanguard or elsewhere the place you will not even have the choice of a free advisor. You may merely refuse the free advisor (general) or sure advise from them if you do not need it with out having to make a change.
Re: Fidelity told me to up stock allocation
Sidneyplace wrote: ↑Tue Sep 17, 2024 2:32 pm
Hello I’m 60 and my husband is 59. We’ve good pensions (about 120k/yr beginning in about 2 years) and round 2.5 million in retirement. Our constancy advisor simply instructed us to extend out portfolio from 60/40 to 70/30. He mentioned they’re altering their outlook at Constancy. What do you assume? And, now-at an all time excessive with uncertainty forward?He mentioned simply do it however I’m questioning why the change and what to do.
[Typo in title corrected. Moderator Pops1860]
My reply to that’s that you need to ask your advisor why the change. If you’re paying for recommendation at Constancy you’re paying them to clarify themselves and you need to get what you’re paying for. Really even in case you are not paying them they need to nonetheless be capable to reply that query.
- Posts: 10049
- Joined: Wed Feb 19, 2014 9:11 am
Re: Fidelity told me to up stock allocation
Post
by SmileyFace »
Not me – however there are many tales I’ve learn in different threads right here about advisors advising people to maneuver out of shares and into an annuity. Is not that the extra frequent advise given by advisors? (Because it permits them to gather charges, and so on.)
- Posts: 117
- Joined: Sat Dec 02, 2023 7:01 pm
Re: Fidelity told me to up stock allocation
Post
by breakfastinbed »
In the event you embrace current worth pension as a part of asset calculations, OP is sitting properly under 60/40, contemplating OP’s pension is “value” greater than the sum of their remaining retirement financial savings.
Re: Fidleity told me to up stock allocation
Sidneyplace wrote: ↑Tue Sep 17, 2024 6:36 pm
Thanks everybody. Simply to clarify-it’s a free Constancy advisor. When you’ve got over 1 million, they’ll assign somebody to you (which is the explanation I switched to them from Vanguard).
Our pensions and SS is not going to cowl all our bills. We’re planning a 4% withdrawal fee. We could have sufficient, however I’m pondering of what we are able to depart for our youngsters and need to optimize finest we are able to. We’ve been very conservative since we do have the pensions. however we want one other 80k/yr so long as we keep in our present scenario and do not plan on altering that for about ten years.I’m open to switching again to Vanguard or have a look at Schwab. Our Constancy individual provides basic recommendation and is aware of our allocations however has not helped me look particularly at what we’re invested in. I’ve by no means discovered an advisor I believed was definitely worth the cash they often cost.
I’ve a kind of free constancy “advisors” too. He snoops at my accounts and infrequently ship me suggestions. The final one was to maneuver all my 401K bonds and steady worth to an IRA cash market. He mentioned you could possibly have $X extra per yr by doing this. I’ve not carried out this (and I first thought of it a yr in the past) as a result of:
- Cash Market charges are about to drop (and so they lastly did right now, a yr later than anticipated however 3 months after the Constancy suggestion to maneuver).
I have been anticipating my steady worth yield to go up. It has at all times lagged, however appears to lag longer than anticipated. I used to be good to have although throughout the low MM charges of 2020-2022 because the steady worth was considerably increased.
- With the yield curve fixing itself, my bond fund has been doing higher this yr. It’s paying greater than the cash market, so higher to go away it the place it’s, particularly for the reason that cash market is now going to yield even decrease with its fee discount.
- I am undecided if I can roll IRA a refund into my 401K after rolling it out. That might preclude me from ever with the ability to put it again into steady worth when the MM pays lower than steady worth. I actually ought to have contacted him to ask that questions, however the one time I referred to as I acquired an answering machine.
So I do take into consideration the Constancy advisor recommendations, however are inclined to ignore their suggestions. He know nothing about my whole monetary image, solely what he sees at Constancy (which is most of it).
Mark |
Someplace in WA State
- Posts: 27066
- Joined: Sat Feb 02, 2008 9:29 am
- Location: Illinois
Re: Fidelity told me to up stock allocation
breakfastinbed wrote: ↑Wed Sep 18, 2024 3:11 pm
In the event you embrace current worth pension as a part of asset calculations, OP is sitting properly under 60/40, contemplating OP’s pension is “value” greater than the sum of their remaining retirement financial savings.
That’s the hazard of utilizing NPV of pension or SS, slightly than subtracting them from annual bills. Can confuse folks into increased inventory allocations than they might in any other case select. In the event you add NPV of earnings streams, you must also add NPV of expense streams.
- Posts: 16486
- Joined: Fri Apr 10, 2015 12:29 am
Re: Fidelity told me to up stock allocation
Post
by Northern Flicker »
breakfastinbed wrote: ↑Wed Sep 18, 2024 3:11 pm
Attention-grabbing how many individuals are recommending switching brokerages over this – any brokerage goes to advocate the identical. I simply took Vanguard’s free investor questionnaire, answering as a conservative investor nearing retirement who’s sitting at 60/40, and the questionnaire really useful I am going to 70/30.
However it might not be primarily based on market outlook or differ with various outlook.