George Carlin Mentioned, 'Do not Simply Train Youngsters To Learn … Train Them To Query Every thing'?

For years, social media customers have shared a quote purportedly attributed to George Carlin, the American comic who died in 2008. The passage learn: “Do not simply educate your youngsters to learn. Train them to query what they learn. Train them to query all the pieces.”

For instance, a Might 2020 Reddit post that includes the quote in a meme had garnered greater than 3,100 upvotes as of this writing. The same post from 2022 acquired 1,900 upvotes.

The quote additionally appeared in quite a few posts on different social media platforms, together with Facebook, Instagram and X, and it was attributed to Carlin on Goodreads.

The citation could possibly be traced again to Carlin. Nevertheless, it paraphrased a press release Carlin made in a comedy particular, quite than immediately quoting him.

The earliest look of the verbatim citation appeared to come back from an X post by the account @TheGeorgeCarlin on April 2, 2013, 5 years after his loss of life. In keeping with the account’s bio: “That is the official George Carlin Twitter, managed by Kelly Carlin and the property of George Carlin.” Kelly Carlin, a writer and podcaster, is the late comic’s daughter.

The precise phrasing of this submit, nonetheless, couldn’t be present in any printed writing or recorded performances from earlier than Carlin died in June 2008.

As a substitute, proof recommended the 2013 X submit paraphrased an genuine assertion by Carlin, as recognized in a 2021 post on GeorgeCarlin.internet. That web site, in keeping with its Regularly Requested Questions page, was created “to deal with and proper the various, many written items on the web which were falsely attributed to George Carlin, and nonetheless proceed to be falsely attributed to him to today.” The web site’s creator, who recognized himself solely as Invoice, famous in the identical FAQ part that he had no affiliation with Carlin’s property.

In keeping with the GeorgeCarlin.internet submit, the unique supply for the paraphrased quote was “It is Unhealthy for Ya,” an HBO comedy special that aired stay in March 2008, simply months earlier than Carlin’s death. The particular additionally was launched as an album that 12 months.

In a recording of the particular uploaded to YouTube in 2022, Carlin delivered the complete quote beginning across the 50:04 timestamp.

 As delivered by Carlin within the recording, the complete model of the quote was as follows:

[It’s] not essential to get youngsters to learn. Youngsters who wanna learn are gonna learn. Youngsters who wish to study to learn are going to study to learn. [It’s] rather more essential to show youngsters to query what they learn. Youngsters ought to be taught to query all the pieces. To query all the pieces they learn, all the pieces they hear.

Snopes approached the Carlin property for affirmation that the 2013 X submit paraphrased the comic’s longer assertion from the 2008 comedy particular. This text can be up to date in the event that they reply.

Nevertheless, given the paraphrased quote was so near the unique, and that the that means and content material remained kind of the identical, we rated this declare “Largely True.”

This is not the primary quote attributed to Carlin that Snopes has investigated. Beforehand, we seemed into the declare the comic as soon as said: “As a substitute of giving children participation trophies, educate them actions the place the result’s the reward.”

Sources