Video Displaying Trump Asking if Crowd Most well-liked Black or White President Is Lacking Some Context

About three weeks from the 2024 U.S. presidential election, on-line customers mentioned a 13-second video displaying former U.S. President Donald Trump talking to a crowd. In line with posts on X, Trump purportedly requested whether or not the gang most popular a Black president or a white president, then remarked, “I feel they need the white man.” Nonetheless, these posts lacked some context.

For instance, in a single publish on Oct. 14, Vice President Kamala Harris’ marketing campaign shared the clip on the @kamalahq fast response account on X (archived). The textual content caption learn, “Would you slightly have the Black president or the white president? I feel they need the white man.” Other users on X additionally shared the identical video. The posts — together with earlier Harris marketing campaign posts on Instagram (archived), Facebook (archived) and TikTok (archived) — included no particulars about the place or when Trump made the comment.

Trump didn’t outright say, because the Harris marketing campaign’s onscreen caption learn, “Would you slightly have the Black president or the white president? I feel they need the white man.” As a substitute, the transient video featured him talking the identical phrases but additionally mentioning a greenback determine, saying, “Would you slightly have the Black president or the white president who obtained $1.7 billion off the value? I feel they need the white man proper now.”

The transient video lacked some context from a narrative Trump had advised seconds earlier than. Additionally, the setting of the speech was in entrance of a Black conservative group. Additional, as of October, the clip was months outdated and didn’t immediately reference Harris. On the time Trump made the remark, President Joe Biden was nonetheless searching for reelection.

The Context of Trump’s Phrases

Trump initially delivered the comment throughout a speech on the Black Conservative Federation Honors Gala. The BCF website describes the group as “the premier hub for Black conservatives all through the nation.” The event befell on the Columbia Metropolitan Conference Middle in Columbia, South Carolina, on Feb. 23, 2024.

Whereas telling a narrative about Air Drive One and the decision signal for when a U.S. president is aboard the plane, Trump referenced its age and likewise former President Barack Obama, telling the BCF viewers, “I like this nice tools. Though the airplane’s 32 years outdated, I ordered new ones, and I saved $1.7 billion from what Obama was prepared to pay. I’ve to let you know, [he’s a] Black president, however I obtained $1.7 billion much less. Would you slightly have the Black president or the white president who obtained $1.7 billion off the value? I feel they need the white man proper now. Bought $1.7 billion off the value.”

On the identical day as Trump’s speech, the @kamalahq account on X — beforehand named @bidenhq — posted (archived) the identical 13-second clip, solely captioning it with the truncated quote, “Trump: Would you slightly have the Black president or the white president? I feel they need the white man.”

The feedback start on the 3:32:58 mark on this full speech video from Proper Aspect Broadcasting Community on YouTube:

In 2023, CNN reported Boeing misplaced $1 billion on every of the 2 747 jets the plane producer agreed to retrofit for future presidential flights, following a fixed-price deal made with Trump in 2018.

Sources