UK regulator calls for modifications to £16.5bn Vodafone-Three merger

Unlock the Editor’s Digest free of charge

Roula Khalaf, Editor of the FT, selects her favorite tales on this weekly e-newsletter.

The UK competitors watchdog has discovered that the proposed £16.5bn merger of Vodafone’s home enterprise with CK Hutchison’s Three UK may result in increased payments for tens of tens of millions of consumers, and demanded that the businesses make modifications to the deal.

The businesses should agree cures for the tie-up to proceed, the Competition and Markets Authority mentioned on Friday, because it introduced the preliminary findings of an in-depth probe into the deal, which was first introduced in 2023. The regulator mentioned it might “discover potential options” to its issues earlier than a remaining choice by December 7.

The merger is anticipated to create the nation’s largest cell operator, and would lower the variety of operators from 4 to 3.

“The investigation . . . has provisionally concluded that the merger would result in value will increase for tens of tens of millions of cell clients, or see clients get a diminished service, reminiscent of smaller information packages of their contracts,” the CMA mentioned in an announcement.

“The CMA has specific issues that increased payments, or diminished companies, would negatively have an effect on these clients least in a position to afford cell companies,” it added.

The CMA opened a “phase 2 investigation” into the deal virtually six months in the past after deciding in an preliminary evaluation that the businesses had not offered sufficient proof that it might profit competitors and funding. 

The competitors watchdog mentioned it had additionally provisionally concluded the deal would negatively have an effect on wholesale clients — cell digital community operators reminiscent of Sky Cellular and Lebara — which use different cell networks to offer their companies.

Cures proposed by the CMA embody legally binding funding commitments overseen by the communications regulator, and measures to guard retail and wholesale clients.

The regulator mentioned it might additionally additional discover a partial divestiture of sure cell community property that would assist competitors for the digital community operators and doubtlessly enable a brand new supplier to enter the market.

The CMA acknowledged that the deal “may enhance the standard of cell networks and convey ahead the deployment of subsequent technology 5G networks and companies”, as claimed by Vodafone and Three UK.

The businesses mentioned in a joint assertion that they “disagree with the CMA’s provisional findings that their merger raises competitors issues and will result in value rises for patrons”, and that they “look ahead to working with the CMA to safe approval”.

When the deal was introduced, the businesses mentioned the merged enterprise would make investments £11bn over 10 years to assist the rollout of 5G networks and that there can be no change to their pricing.

Robert Finnegan, chief govt of Three UK, mentioned the present UK cell market was “dysfunctional and lacks high quality competitors” and the businesses had been “decided to reassure the CMA” and “work with them to safe the intensive advantages this merger brings”.

Tom Smith, a contest lawyer at Geradin Companions and former CMA authorized director mentioned: “The CMA not often modifications its thoughts between the provisional choice and the ultimate choice, so the main focus will now transfer on to the effectiveness of the varied treatment choices.”

“The CMA has raised a spread of potential cures, together with supervising the funding guarantees whereas defending shoppers from value rises within the meantime. One of these behavioural treatment can be extremely uncommon in CMA merger instances,” he added.