Este artículo estará disponible en español en El Tiempo Latino.
In his continued assault on the federal response to Hurricane Helene, former President Donald Trump falsely stated that no helicopters and no assist have been despatched to the affected areas for days, blaming Vice President Kamala Harris. There’s loads of proof that helicopters have been used and that federal, state and native catastrophe restoration groups have responded to assist victims of the storm.
On Sept. 29, for instance, the Military Nationwide Guard stated that 1000’s of Guard members had rescued lots of of individuals, together with with helicopters, and cleared roads within the a number of states impacted by the hurricane.
Trump, who’s making hurricane response misinformation a part of his pitch to voters within the final weeks of the presidential marketing campaign, said at an Oct. 9 rally in Studying, Pennsylvania: “Whereas households desperately tried to flee the rising floodwaters and so they climbed onto roofs, they did something they’ll to stay, however Kamala didn’t ship any helicopters to rescue them. And when folks despatched helicopters, they turned them again. … . So she didn’t ship something or anybody in any respect. Days handed, no assist, as males, girls and youngsters drowned.”
It was a extra colourful model of what he said in Butler, Pennsylvania, on Oct. 5. “Kamala wined and dined in San Francisco,” he stated, referring to a Sept. 28 marketing campaign fundraiser Harris attended within the metropolis, “and all the folks in North Carolina — no helicopters, no rescue.” (He went on to falsely recommend, as we wrote, that folks whose properties have been destroyed would solely get $750.)
We requested the Trump marketing campaign to clarify what he was referring to when claiming there have been no helicopters or assist, and that helicopters have been turned away, however we didn’t get a response. It seems he’s ignoring the Nationwide Guard and FEMA sources and talking solely concerning the deployment of active-duty troops, a deployment that governors request.
Hurricane Helene made landfall on Florida’s Gulf Coast late on Sept. 26 and rain from the tropical storm subsequently prompted severe flooding and widespread injury to components of North Carolina, South Carolina, Georgia, Tennessee and Virginia.
As we stated, the Military Nationwide Guard reported that 1000’s of Guard members — greater than 6,600 from 17 states — have been engaged in restoration efforts, as of Sept. 29. The Guard press launch listed particulars concerning the personnel deployed and the actions taken in numerous states. Particularly in North Carolina, which Trump talked about and which skilled catastrophic flooding within the western space of the state within the Blue Ridge Mountains, greater than 900 Guard members, together with some from 11 different states, “cleared roads, transported commodities and carried out search and rescue missions with helicopters,” the Guard stated. Greater than 100,000 kilos of meals and different provides have been delivered to the Asheville airport by navy cargo aircraft.
On Sept. 28, the state of North Carolina said that search and rescue operations had been ongoing within the western a part of the state. “Greater than 200 folks have been rescued from flood waters in North Carolina following Helene’s torrential rains,” the governor’s workplace stated in a press launch, including that the state’s “search and rescue groups are being bolstered by groups from 19 states and three federal groups.”
A Washington Submit reporter wrote about flying on Oct. 2 with a North Carolina Nationwide Guard Black Hawk crew that had been flying “for a number of days straight” as a part of restoration efforts. “The drone of helicopters has grow to be routine throughout western North Carolina within the wake of Helene,” the story stated. “Nationwide Guard and civilian plane now crisscross the skies of a area the place roads and bridges have been destroyed and individuals are trapped.”
The next day, the state Nationwide Guard said it had accomplished “146 flight missions, ensuing within the rescue of 538 folks and 150 pets.”
In Tennessee, “service members from the 1-230th Assault Helicopter Battalion, based mostly at Knoxville’s Joint Base McGhee-Tyson and Nashville’s Berry Discipline, have rescued over 100 folks and transported over 34,000 kilos of ingesting water, meals, turbines and different gear to these in want,” in response to the Guard’s Sept. 29 press launch.
Hundreds of federal staff have been engaged on response efforts, the Federal Emergency Administration Company said in a Sept. 30 launch, the day that FEMA Administrator Deanne Criswell visited North Carolina. “Greater than 3,500 personnel from throughout the federal workforce are deployed and supporting Hurricane Helene response efforts throughout the impacted states – greater than 1,000 are from FEMA,” it stated.
The press launch listed the quantity of meals, water, turbines, ambulances, Starlink satellite tv for pc methods and different provides that had been despatched to affected areas. In North Carolina, it stated, there have been 10 search and rescue groups “on the bottom,” with one other 9 groups arriving that day. In Knoxville, Tennessee, there have been about 90 federal City Search & Rescue personnel. The discharge listed different ways in which federal, state and native officers, in addition to volunteer teams such because the American Purple Cross and personal sector companions have been supporting the efforts. “The Division of Protection has 30 high-water vans prepared to help rescuers and 18 helicopters that may transport provides, gear and groups,” it stated.
In a Sept. 30 briefing, Protection Division spokesperson Sabrina Singh additionally spoke of the “multi-state, multi-agency effort” involving Nationwide Guard members. She stated that “a crew for command and management for top water automobiles and air operations assist for rotary wing plane has been established at Fort Liberty, North Carolina,” mentioning the helicopters can be there that day and the high-water automobiles have been at Fort Campbell.
As for active-duty troops, governors request such deployments by FEMA.
“Governors are in command of the response of their state, not FEMA or DoD,” Craig Fugate, FEMA administrator throughout President Barack Obama’s administration and beforehand director of the Florida Division of Emergency Administration, informed us in an electronic mail. “As to activating Troops on Federal Responsibility (10 Title 10), that request comes from the Governor for assist to FEMA.” FEMA can then ask the Protection Division, “if FEMA has no different technique to meet the requirement,” and the Protection Division makes the willpower of what it might probably do and assigns the mission to U.S. Northern Command, which coordinates with FEMA on the deployments.
Fugate famous that the Nationwide Guard’s position in catastrophe response is crucial.
In Studying, Trump additionally stated, “It took six days earlier than Kamala and Joe despatched a small variety of troops to assist.” That echoes a declare his operating mate, Sen. JD Vance, made in an Oct. 8 Wall Road Journal op-ed, which didn’t point out the Nationwide Guard, however stated: “On Oct. 2, six days after the storm made landfall, the Protection Division announced that 1,000 troops had been approved to deploy to the hurricane-response zone, together with components of the 82nd Airborne Division from Fort Liberty, N.C.”
The linked press launch, from North Carolina’s governor, Roy Cooper, a Democrat, stated that President Joe Biden had authorised Cooper’s request for the active-duty troops and gear. Vance claimed there had been “a bureaucratic bottleneck” that delayed the troops being authorised or despatched.
We will’t decide whether or not there was an pointless delay. After we requested Cooper’s workplace concerning the declare, Jordan Monaghan, deputy communications director for the governor, stated in a press release: “Governor Cooper requested President Biden on Monday September 30 to make all obligatory federal sources accessible to reply to this catastrophic storm. Additionally on September 30, the Governor requested that the Division of Protection approve Brigadier Basic Charles W. Morrison, North Carolina Military Nationwide Guard, because the Twin Standing Commander for any active-duty navy assigned obligation in North Carolina beneath Title X.”
A twin standing commander can serve in federal and state statuses on the identical time.
“The Division of Protection authorised this request on Wednesday, October 2 and the Nationwide Guard and lively obligation forces started a coordinated deployment into impacted counties,” Monaghan stated. “Title 10 aviation property and together with helicopters and pilots deployed nearly instantly on October 2 and three and 1,500 lively obligation navy personnel have deployed to western North Carolina since October 3, with extra on the way in which.”
We requested Monaghan to make clear whether or not Cooper requested the active-duty troops on Sept. 30 as properly, however we haven’t acquired a response.
At an Oct. 10 Pentagon press briefing, Press Secretary Maj. Gen. Pat Ryder was requested when the FEMA request got here in to the Protection Division for the active-duty troops for North Carolina. He said he didn’t have the dates, however, “I do know that we clearly responded in a short time after receiving the request.”
Monaghan additionally stated: “This can be a huge response involving gear and 1000’s of personnel from the Nationwide Guard, US Military, state and native first responders and emergency managers, FEMA and others. It have to be intently coordinated to satisfy instant emergency wants and set up a long-term restoration. Each effort is being made to maximise pace, coordination and impression of sources and personnel at each degree, and Governor Cooper appreciates the numerous extra capabilities delivered to this effort by our Lively obligation forces.”
He stated that disinformation on-line and from Trump and different politicians was a “vital hurdle” within the catastrophe response.
Trump is free to criticize the Biden administration, in fact, however claiming there have been “no helicopters” or assist for victims of the storm in North Carolina is fake. And pointing to the deployment of active-duty troops ignores the big position of the Nationwide Guard and federal sources apart from the U.S. navy.
Editor’s word: FactCheck.org doesn’t settle for promoting. We depend on grants and particular person donations from folks such as you. Please take into account a donation. Bank card donations could also be made by our “Donate” page. When you choose to offer by verify, ship to: FactCheck.org, Annenberg Public Coverage Middle, 202 S. thirty sixth St., Philadelphia, PA 19104.
