Former President Donald Trump mentioned FBI knowledge that present homicides and different violent crimes trending down are “pretend numbers.” They’re not.
The FBI knowledge for 2023 are preliminary, however crime statistics specialists say the reporting behind the general downward pattern is stable, and that pattern is validated when in comparison with knowledge samples from native and state legislation enforcement reviews.
The FBI statistics contradict Trump’s marketing campaign narrative, repeated at a Could 1 rally in Wisconsin, about rampant and rising violent crime within the U.S. And polls that show most People imagine crime is on the rise. However that doesn’t imply the knowledge are unsuitable or “fudged,” as Trump put it.
The FBI statistics are, nevertheless, incomplete, provided that they measure solely crimes reported to legislation enforcement — some crimes, similar to rape, are traditionally enormously underreported — and never each legislation enforcement company reviews its statistics. That has been the case for many years.
Trump’s dismissal of the validity of the FBI’s crime statistics reminds us of when Trump was working for president in 2016 and falsely labeled the unemployment charges printed by the Bureau of Labor Statistics as “phony numbers.”
At the moment, Trump claimed the unemployment price was actually 42%. (The official unemployment price then was 4.9%.) Lower than two months after Trump took workplace, nevertheless, he was completely happy to quote BLS’ official unemployment price. Sean Spicer, Trump’s high spokesman on the time, joked in a press briefing about Trump’s new embrace of the roles knowledge, “Yeah, I talked to the president previous to this, and he mentioned to cite him very clearly — ‘They could have been phony prior to now, nevertheless it’s very actual now.’”
In line with the FBI’s preliminary 2023 crime report, violent crimes dropped 5.7% between 2022 and 2023, and the variety of murders declined 13.2%. That’s based mostly on knowledge from 79% of legislation enforcement businesses within the U.S., representing larger participation than any yr throughout Trump’s presidency. Murders and violent crime went up in 2020, Trump’s final yr in workplace, and murders continued to rise in 2021, albeit to a lesser extent, as violent crime ticked down a bit. Each have been declining since, in line with FBI and different crime knowledge.
Requested in regards to the downward pattern in violent crime figures in a Time interview carried out on April 12, Trump mentioned he didn’t imagine it, and he claimed, “The FBI gave pretend numbers.”
Time Nationwide Politics Reporter Eric Cortellessa, April 12: Violent crime goes down all through the nation. There was a 6% drop in—
Trump: I don’t imagine it.
Cortellessa: You don’t imagine that?
Trump: Yeah, they’re pretend numbers.
Cortellessa: You assume so?
Trump: Nicely it got here out final night time. The FBI gave pretend numbers.
Cortellessa: I didn’t see that, however the FBI mentioned that there was a 13% drop [in homicides] in 2023.
Trump: I don’t imagine it. No, it’s a lie. It’s pretend information.
Cortellessa: Sir, these numbers are collected by state and native police departments throughout the nation. Most of them assist you. Are they unsuitable?
Trump: Yeah. Final night time. Nicely, possibly, possibly not. The FBI fudged the numbers and different folks fudged numbers. There isn’t any means that crime went down during the last yr. There’s no means as a result of you’ve gotten migrant crime. Are they including migrant crime? Or do they think about {that a} completely different type of crime?
Cortellessa: So these native police departments are unsuitable?
Trump: I don’t imagine it’s from the native police. What I noticed was the FBI was giving false numbers.
We reached out to Trump’s press workplace for clarification about what Trump was referring to when he mentioned, “it got here out final night time” that “[t]he FBI gave pretend numbers.” We additionally requested for some other proof to assist Trump’s declare the FBI “fudged the numbers.” We acquired no response.
The FBI figures are based mostly on voluntary reviews by businesses nationwide. The ultimate numbers and details about nationwide crime charges, that are adjusted for inhabitants, gained’t be obtainable till the FBI’s annual crime report is launched in October.
“This knowledge is preliminary and unaudited so businesses have time to submit knowledge for extra months or repair obvious knowledge errors (of which there are a handful), nevertheless it’s knowledge coming from businesses themselves,” crime analyst Jeff Asher, co-founder of the New Orleans agency AH Datalytics, informed us through electronic mail. “I like to consider these figures as correct however not exact.”
In different phrases, he mentioned, the drop in murders might find yourself being 10% or 11% decrease in 2023 as an alternative of 13.2%. And the drop in violent crime could also be smaller than the 5.7% within the preliminary report. However, he mentioned, the preliminary knowledge “highlights the pattern of quickly declining homicide and fewer quickly declining violent crime.”
The downward murder pattern is backed up by AH Datalytics’ analysis of information about homicides from greater than 200 massive U.S. cities, which confirmed homicides declined by about 12% in 2023, Asher mentioned. The FBI knowledge additionally monitor with a big decline in capturing victims in 2023 documented by the Gun Violence Archives.
“Homicide nearly actually declined at one of many quickest charges ever recorded in 2023,” Asher wrote in his 2023 analysis.
As for the downward pattern in violent crime, that “is seemingly backed up by publicly obtainable data from 14 states that printed their knowledge already exhibiting a decline in violent crime in most states,” Asher mentioned.
The Council on Felony Justice’s crime report for 2023, printed in January, discovered that homicides in 32 cities that supplied such knowledge had been 10% decrease—representing 515 fewer homicides—in 2023 than in 2022. The CCJ evaluation additionally discovered there have been 3% fewer reported aggravated assaults and seven% fewer gun assaults in 11 reporting cities, and 5% fewer carjackings in 10 reporting cities. The report discovered robberies and home violence incidents every rose 2% in 2023.
“Total, crime charges are largely returning to pre-COVID ranges because the nation distances itself from the peak of the pandemic, however there are notable exceptions.” the CCJ report states. “Whereas decreases in murder within the examine cities (and plenty of different cities) are promising, the progress is uneven and different sources of crime info, together with family surveys of violent victimization, point out larger charges and extra pronounced shifts than reviews to legislation enforcement businesses.”
The most recent figures from the Main Cities Chiefs Affiliation additionally show a decline in murders and violent crime. The variety of murders went down by 10.4% from 2022 to 2023 in 69 massive U.S. cities that supplied knowledge, in line with its report. Since 2020, murders in these cities have dropped by 8.6%. The latest report from MCCA exhibits violent crime continued to pattern down within the first quarter of 2024, although homicides and different violent crimes stay above their pre-pandemic 2019 ranges.
“Given the multitude of information sources pointing to the identical widespread decline I’d say the FBI quarterly knowledge is reliable by way of the overarching pattern whereas there nonetheless being a good quantity of uncertainty as to how massive the declines in homicide and violent crime might have been,” Asher mentioned.
Richard Berk, emeritus professor of criminology and statistics on the College of Pennsylvania, agrees. “Violent crime typically seems to have been declining submit COVID,” Berk informed us through electronic mail.
“It’s clearly taking place in the best way it’s described” by the FBI, Berk mentioned. And if you happen to doubt that, he mentioned, “In the event you use native knowledge (e.g., from the Philly PD) you’ll be able to bypass claims of FBI malfeasance. And if you happen to try this, you get just about the identical story.”
Nonetheless, he mentioned, the method of monitoring crime within the U.S. is “a really imperfect system.” For one, some violent crimes — similar to rape and home violence — are much more underreported to police than others.
Crime Victimization Survey
The FBI’s Uniform Crime Report paperwork crimes reported to legislation enforcement. The federal government’s different nationwide crime measure is the National Crime Victimization Survey, which estimates ranges of varied crimes based mostly on a survey of about 240,000 folks annually, asking whether or not they have been victims of varied crimes. The 2 measures can differ, and have in recent times.
Whereas the FBI Uniform Crime Stories had been exhibiting a lower in violent crime between 2021 and 2022, the NCVS for 2022 — the newest yr obtainable — confirmed the serious violent crime victimization price — which incorporates rape and sexual assault, theft, and aggravated assault — rose from 5.6 the yr earlier than to 9.8 violent crimes per 1,000 inhabitants age 12 and older.
In an October report, criminologists on the Council on Felony Justice wrote that the divergence between the FBI’s Uniform Crime Report and the NCVS “makes it unsure whether or not violent crime really went up or down in 2022.”
Nonetheless, that also doesn’t assist Trump’s declare.
“These findings from the Nationwide Crime Victimization Survey present that the 2022 price of nonfatal violent victimization elevated in comparison with 2021, however was just like the speed in 2018 and remained a lot decrease than the highs of the early Nineties,” Kevin M. Scott, principal deputy director of the Bureau of Justice Statistics, mentioned in a press release in regards to the report for 2022.
Asher mentioned there are quite a few causes the NCVS doesn’t nullify the developments reported within the FBI’s Uniform Crime Report.
The NCVS “is terrific for outlining the contours of what does and doesn’t get reported however isn’t notably nice at measuring year-to-year developments,” Asher informed us. In a post on April 8, Asher outlined a few of the causes for the discrepancy between the reviews in 2022.
“The obvious purpose to keep away from year-to-year direct comparisons is that UCR counts homicide whereas NCVS doesn’t,” Asher wrote. “Homicide victims can’t be surveyed, so the rationale for the crime’s absence is smart in NCVS, nevertheless it’s additionally the crime that comes with the best societal value and I’m guessing it’s normally the crime that individuals are interested by when they consider the nation’s violent crime price. Homicide can be the one crime that in all probability has decently correct — albeit imperfect — counts annually.”
Murders have indisputably gone down in every of the final two years, after a spike in 2020 and a smaller uptick in 2021, although they’re nonetheless a bit larger than 2019.
Asher additionally cites a lag time constructed into surveys that ask about crimes during the last six months, the truth that the surveys solely embrace folks 12 and older, and that surveys — by definition — have margins of error.
Asher additionally notes that the NCVS’ most up-to-date survey is for 2022, whereas the preliminary FBI knowledge is for 2023.
“In some ways, 2022’s violent crime pattern isn’t notably vital relative to the course implied in 2023’s preliminary reported crime trend sitting right here within the spring of 2024,” Asher wrote.
In an op-ed for the Wall Avenue Journal on April 24, John Lott, an economist and president of the Crime Prevention Analysis Heart, argued that the NCVS has revealed that violent crime isn’t down, simply reporting of violent crime to police departments. He attributes that to massive cities arresting fewer folks, and thereby giving victims much less incentive to report against the law.
“Legislation enforcement has collapsed within the U.S., notably in huge cities,” Lott wrote, and “many People [are] now not assured that the authorized system will shield them.”
Certainly, Ernesto Lopez, a analysis specialist on the Council on Felony Justice, mentioned the NCVS indicated that “non-reporting of aggravated assaults elevated by about 29% from 2021 to 2022,” which he mentioned, “might create an undercount of aggravated assaults.” Nonetheless, he mentioned, “I typically wouldn’t classify the FBI knowledge as inaccurate.”
Lott, whose controversial analysis on crime and weapons is often cited by conservatives, additionally attributes the discrepancy between the 2022 FBI and NCVS knowledge to low participation amongst native police departments that feed knowledge to tell the FBI report. However participation charges in 2023 grew considerably.
A Change in Reporting Knowledge
As we have written, beginning in 2021, the FBI transitioned to a brand new system for native legislation enforcement businesses to submit knowledge, requiring businesses to make use of what’s referred to as the National Incident-Based Reporting System. That first yr, solely 60% of agencies reported crime knowledge — police departments within the two largest U.S. cities, New York City and Los Angeles, had been among the many notable non-reporters — and so the FBI and the Bureau of Justice Statistics provided national estimates to fill within the gaps. As a result of low reporting degree, some crime knowledge specialists cautioned to not make sweeping conclusions about crime developments.
Anna Harvey, a politics, knowledge science and legislation professor at New York College, was amongst those that warned on the time that politicians had been “form of throwing round allegations and claims about crime that will or is probably not correct.”
In an electronic mail interview, Harvey informed us participation charges have since improved dramatically.
The yr the FBI transitioned to the NIBRS system for gathering crime knowledge — 2021 — she mentioned, solely 60% of agencies reported. That elevated to 71% in 2022, “which was higher however nonetheless worse than pre-NIBRS charges,” Harvey mentioned.
However the preliminary 2023 FBI report — the one which discovered a 13.2% drop in murders and a 5.7% decline in violent crimes in 2023 in contrast with 2022 — is predicated on 79.4% of businesses reporting.
“That’s fairly good!” Harvey mentioned. “It’s larger than any reporting price in the course of the Trump presidency, and shut to the best noticed reporting rate between 2000 and 2022 (81%).”
‘Migrant Crime’
Trump argued that the FBI crime statistics should have been “fudged” as a result of they didn’t account for a wave of “migrant crime.”
“There isn’t any means that crime went down during the last yr,” Trump mentioned within the Time interview. “There’s no means as a result of you’ve gotten migrant crime. Are they including migrant crime? Or do they think about {that a} completely different type of crime?”
Crime knowledge specialists say Trump confuses how FBI crime knowledge are collected and reported.
“The FBI UCR statistics don’t monitor incidents similar to unlawful entries, failure to seem in hearings, and so on.,” Lopez, of the Council on Felony Justice, informed us. “Nevertheless, if a migrant commits an offense, similar to a theft, and that theft is reported to the police, and that police division reviews their crime incidents to the FBI, that incident will probably be mirrored in official statistics.”
To make sure, there have been numerous high-profile crimes dedicated by immigrants within the nation illegally this yr, together with the homicide of nursing scholar Laken Riley in February and an assault on New York Metropolis law enforcement officials in January.
However Asher, of AH Datalytics, says there isn’t any proof within the knowledge to point a migrant crime wave. Asher mentioned that assuming a wave of crimes being dedicated by immigrants was too small to register in total nationwide developments of reported violent crime, he determined to analyze crime knowledge to see if it was at the least exhibiting up alongside the U.S. border with Mexico. And so he checked out Texas crime knowledge.
“Evaluating violent crime charges in Texas border counties over time to violent crime within the US and statewide in Texas exhibits no proof of accelerating violent crime alongside the US border with Mexico,” Asher wrote. “The 14 counties alongside the Texas-Mexico border have seen a comparatively regular violent crime price beneath that of the remainder of their state and the nation as a complete.”
“There are — and sure all the time will probably be — terribly tragic particular person incidents of crime to level to as anecdotal proof of no matter wider pattern one needs to claim,” Asher wrote. “However particular person tragedies don’t inherently represent against the law wave, and the shortage of an overarching surge in incidents shouldn’t detract from the tragedy of particular person examples.
“In the end, the US crime knowledge system is poorly set as much as definitively reply the query of whether or not there may be an immigrant-driven crime wave,” he mentioned. “That mentioned, the general pattern of declining violent crime nationally, and seeing no localized crime surges within the locations I’d count on to see one if there was such a ‘wave’ strongly means that no such factor exists.”
A February New York Times evaluation discovered that whereas 170,000 migrants have arrived in New York Metropolis since April 2022 — when Texas Gov. Greg Abbott started bussing migrants there to name consideration to rising unlawful immigration into his state — “the general crime price has stayed flat. And, in reality, many main classes of crime — together with rape, homicide and shootings — have decreased.”
Jeffrey Butts, director of the Analysis and Analysis Heart on the John Jay Faculty of Felony Justice, informed the New York Occasions there was no proof of a migrant crime wave.
“I might interpret a ‘wave’ to imply one thing important, significant and a departure from the norm,” Butts mentioned. “To date, what we have now are particular person incidents of crime.”
An ‘Imperfect’ System
The FBI’s Uniform Crime Stories are an “imperfect” solution to measure crime within the U.S., Berk mentioned. There isn’t uniform compliance amongst reporting businesses, and the report solely captures crimes reported to legislation enforcement.
“Total crime is a composite of many various sorts of crimes, some are fairly frequent and a few are fairly uncommon,” Berk mentioned. “Total measures could be dominated by the commonest crimes. Crimes similar to murder, which is what has nice political clout, are comparatively uncommon. The idea of total crime is principally nonsense.”
“The very best again of envelope solution to proceed is to concentrate on specific crimes one after the other and one jurisdiction at a time,” Berk mentioned. “However there are subtitles right here too. For instance, homicides can fall even when the variety of shootings will increase insofar as medical care considerably improves, similar to with the ‘scoop and run’ coverage of the Philly PD. Trauma facilities actually assist as nicely.
“However, violent crime typically seems to have been declining submit COVID,” Berk mentioned.
In different phrases, there are quite a few caveats that go together with crime statistics just like the FBI’s Uniform Crime Stories. The info have sure limitations. However crime knowledge specialists say they’re helpful and informative, and there’s no purpose to imagine they’re “pretend” or “fudged,” as Trump claimed.
With a view to test the FBI knowledge, Berk mentioned, merely have a look at the crime reviews from varied cities and you will note they typically match up with the information reported by the FBI for that metropolis, he mentioned.
“It’s arduous to argue there’s a conspiracy [by the FBI to fudge the data] if the native police departments are giving them the statistics,” Berk mentioned. “You may say [for example] the Philadelphia police division is in cahoots with the Biden administration’s FBI, however that’s merely a foolish conspiracy idea.”
Editor’s word: FactCheck.org doesn’t settle for promoting. We depend on grants and particular person donations from folks such as you. Please think about a donation. Bank card donations could also be made by our “Donate” page. In the event you favor to present by test, ship to: FactCheck.org, Annenberg Public Coverage Heart, 202 S. thirty sixth St., Philadelphia, PA 19104.
