Este artículo estará disponible en español en El Tiempo Latino.
In marketing campaign appearances over the weekend within the swing state of Pennsylvania, former President Donald Trump and his operating mate, Sen. JD Vance, falsely accused Vice President Kamala Harris of letting greater than 13,000 “unlawful immigrant murderers” into the USA.
It’s true that there have been 13,099 noncitizens convicted of homicide, as of July 21, who weren’t being detained by the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement.
However the “overwhelming majority” of them entered the nation previous to the Biden administration and had their custody standing decided “lengthy earlier than this Administration,” the Division of Homeland Safety mentioned in an announcement, noting that many had been in jail. Additionally, the noncitizens embody those that entered the nation legally, reminiscent of green-card holders.
Trump and Vance distorted the contents of a Sept. 25 letter that Patrick Lechleitner, the appearing director of ICE, despatched to Rep. Tony Gonzales. The Republican congressman had requested the variety of noncitizens who had dedicated against the law however weren’t in ICE custody — an inventory often called the company’s non-detained docket.
Lechleitner’s response included a chart that confirmed there are 13,099 noncitizens convicted of homicide who weren’t being detained by ICE. Homeland Safety later clarified in its assertion that “many” are in prisons, though it didn’t inform us what number of are incarcerated once we inquired.
Gonzales posted Lechleitner’s letter to X on Sept. 27. The subsequent day, Vance referenced the 13,099 murderers at a marketing campaign occasion in Newtown, Pennsylvania, and Trump did the identical in Prairie du Chien, Wisconsin. A day later, Trump repeated the declare in Erie, Pennsylvania.
Vance, Sept. 28: Are you aware that there are 13,000 — I do know a few of you’re nodding as a result of a few of you noticed this — 13,000 unlawful immigrant murderers in the USA of America proper now. They’re on this nation as a result of Kamala Harris allow them to on this nation.
Trump, Sept. 29: Throughout her time period, it’s not even plausible, she let in 13,099 convicted murderers. A few of them had murdered 10 folks, some murdered seven. One murdered six.
In its assertion, the Division of Homeland Safety mentioned knowledge in Lechleitner’s letter had been “misinterpreted.”
“The info goes again a long time; it consists of people who entered the nation over the previous 40 years or extra, the overwhelming majority of whose custody willpower was made lengthy earlier than this Administration,” the assertion mentioned. “It additionally consists of many who’re underneath the jurisdiction or at the moment incarcerated by federal, state or native regulation enforcement companions.”
Equally, Michelle Mittelstadt, director of communications for the nonpartisan Migration Coverage Institute, advised us that individuals have been on the non-detained docket “for many years.”
“There’s lots of confusion across the non-detained docket,” together with “who’s on it and the way lengthy they’ve been on it,” Mittelstadt mentioned in an e-mail. “This docket has grown underneath a number of administrations, together with the Trump one. Vital numbers of individuals on the docket have been on it for many years.”
For instance, the ICE appearing director mentioned in his letter that there are 425,431 convicted criminals on the company’s non-detained docket as of July 21. However, as Mittelstadt famous, ICE reported in a budget document “that there have been 405,786 convicted felony noncitizens on the non-detained docket in June 2021 – so the overwhelming majority would have gotten on through the prior administrations because the Biden administration by then was simply 5 months previous.” The variety of folks on the docket has elevated by almost 5% in about three years.
She additionally advised us that “the non-detained docket consists of not simply unauthorized immigrants however green-card holders and noncitizens on long-term non-immigrant visas who’ve made themselves detachable by advantage of a felony conviction.”
The ICE letter to Gonzales did present that, as of July 21, there have been an extra 1,845 noncitizens on the non-detained docket who face homicide expenses. However, once more, we don’t know when these 1,845 folks entered the USA, what number of of them might have entered illegally and once they dedicated their alleged crimes. We additionally have no idea if they’re being held by different native, state or federal regulation enforcement businesses. A Homeland Safety spokesperson didn’t reply once we requested for such info.
We requested the Trump marketing campaign to answer the proof that contradicts its candidates’ claims that Harris let 13,099 “unlawful immigrant murderers” into the USA. We additionally requested it to provide details about Trump’s declare that among the 13,099 “had murdered 10 folks, some murdered seven.” In response, Karoline Leavitt, Trump’s nationwide press secretary, mentioned Trump “will start the most important mass deportation in historical past on day one.”
Mittelstadt mentioned some murderers and different criminals can’t be deported “as a result of their nation is not going to settle for their return.” As well as, she mentioned, a 2001 Supreme Court docket ruling typically bars ICE from detaining noncitizens for greater than six months if they’re unlikely to be deported. Because of this, ICE says on its web site that it “has been legally required to launch hundreds of noncitizens, together with these with critical felony convictions.”
Editor’s notice: FactCheck.org doesn’t settle for promoting. We depend on grants and particular person donations from folks such as you. Please contemplate a donation. Bank card donations could also be made by our “Donate” page. When you favor to provide by examine, ship to: FactCheck.org, Annenberg Public Coverage Heart, 202 S. thirty sixth St., Philadelphia, PA 19104.
