Este artículo estará disponible en español en El Tiempo Latino.
Fast Take
Social media posts misleadingly declare that “Trump’s Venture 2025 will finish” the Federal Emergency Administration Company and supply “ZERO federal assist” to catastrophe victims. Venture 2025 is just not former President Donald Trump’s plan, and there’s no proof that he would “finish” FEMA. In reality, his administration spent tens of billions on catastrophe assist when he was president.
Full Story
Hurricane Helene, which made landfall on Sept. 26 in northwest Florida, precipitated destruction throughout six southeastern states and has claimed a minimum of 231 lives, making it one of the deadliest hurricanes to strike the U.S. mainland since Hurricane Katrina.
Federal help for Helene exceeded $344 million by Oct. 9, and the Federal Emergency Administration Company has deployed hundreds of personnel, assessed harm and offered important assist, together with meals, water, turbines and tarps, to the affected areas. The extent of the harm would require “a multibillion-dollar, multiyear restoration” effort, Division of Homeland Safety Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas said.
As Hurricane Milton slammed into Florida’s western coast on the night of Oct. 9 with what the Nationwide Climate Service known as a “life-threatening” storm surge, FEMA is within the eye of a misinformation storm. (The unfold of false claims has change into so pervasive that the company has launched a devoted “Rumor Response” page for Hurricane Helene, following related pages launched through the COVID-19 pandemic and former disasters.)
Latest social media posts have made deceptive claims about the way forward for FEMA if former President Donald Trump returns to the White Home.
“Trumps Venture 2025 will finish FEMA,” an Oct. 2 Threads post claimed.
“If Donald Trump have been president at present, he would inform North Carolina they’re on their very own and getting ZERO federal assist. How do we all know this? It’s in Venture 2025,” one other Threads user wrote.
Project 2025, which is being led and funded by the conservative Heritage Basis, is an in depth plan to scale back the scale and scope of presidency beneath “the following conservative President.” We have written extensively in regards to the venture and have debunked false and misleading claims about it.
Though parts of it have been developed by former Trump aides, Venture 2025 isn’t a Trump marketing campaign doc and the previous president has distanced himself from it.
“I’ve nothing to do with Venture 2025,” Trump said through the Sept. 10 debate. “This was a bunch of folks that received collectively, they got here up with some concepts. I suppose some good, some unhealthy. However it makes no distinction. I’ve nothing to do [with it].”
There additionally isn’t any proof to help the declare that Trump would “finish FEMA” or present “zero federal assist” if he will get again into workplace.
Trump marketing campaign spokesperson Karoline Leavitt informed us in an electronic mail that the social media claims are “pretend information.”
Throughout his presidency, Trump approved tens of billions in catastrophe help by way of FEMA. From fiscal years 2017 to 2020, a interval spanning a part of former President Barack Obama’s tenure and most of Trump’s time in workplace, FEMA spent almost $94 billion from the Catastrophe Reduction Fund, according to the Congressional Price range Workplace. In FY2018 alone, the company allotted almost $23 billion for restoration efforts following three main hurricanes within the 2017 hurricane season: Harvey, Irma and Maria.
FEMA said the variety of functions for help throughout Harvey was “one of many highest in FEMA historical past.” Inside simply 30 days, greater than $1.5 billion in federal assist was distributed to Texans affected by the storm, protecting help grants, low-interest catastrophe loans and advance funds for flood insurance coverage, in response to FEMA.
Opposite to social media claims, Trump additionally has made feedback through the present presidential marketing campaign that point out he’ll proceed to help federal catastrophe help.
Trump has criticized the Biden administration for not doing sufficient throughout Hurricane Helene. Trump posted on Truth Social on Oct. 9, saying, “They will’t get something carried out correctly, however I’ll make up for misplaced time, and do it proper, after I get there.”
Venture 2025 isn’t calling for the elimination of FEMA, both, though specialists say the adjustments it proposes would undermine the company.
“Fairly than ‘reducing’ FEMA, Venture 2025 is advocating for a realignment of the company’s mission and focus – away from DEI [diversity, equity and inclusion] and local weather change initiatives and restoring it to that of serving to folks earlier than, throughout, and after disasters,” a Venture 2025 spokesperson informed us in an electronic mail.
The venture’s policy agenda, which was printed on-line in “Mandate for Management: The Conservative Promise,” proposes adjustments to FEMA in a chapter written by Ken Cuccinelli, who served as appearing deputy secretary of the Division of Homeland Safety within the Trump administration. It recommends that FEMA “be moved to the Division of the Inside or, if mixed with the [Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency], to the Division of Transportation.”
“FEMA is the lead federal company in getting ready for and responding to disasters, however it’s overtasked, overcompensates for the shortage of state and native preparedness and response, and is often in deep debt,” Venture 2025 says.
The plan requires “reforming FEMA emergency spending to shift the vast majority of preparedness and response prices to states and localities as a substitute of the federal authorities, eliminating most of DHS’s grant packages.”
Consultants: Venture 2025 Would Weaken FEMA
Consultants say claims on social media that Venture 2025 will “finish FEMA” should not correct, however the plan’s proposed adjustments to FEMA’s construction may undermine its capacity to successfully reply to disasters.
“This concept that Venture 2025 and Trump would eradicate FEMA is simply not true,” Jeffrey Schlegelmilch, director of the Nationwide Middle for Catastrophe Preparedness at Columbia College, informed us in a telephone interview. “There clearly is a job for FEMA. It’s only a diminished function in a diminished capability, which I feel wouldn’t be good for fairness, wouldn’t be good for the rising hazards that we face.”
“I feel what [Project 2025} would do was really bring it back to where it was at the time of Hurricane Katrina. … And we all know how that worked out,” Schlegelmilch said, referring to FEMA’s failures in New Orleans and the Gulf Coast in 2005.
FEMA was established in 1979 by then-President Jimmy Carter to coordinate the federal government’s response to disasters and emergencies. Initially, it was an independent agency focused on disaster response and recovery efforts. In 2003, FEMA was transferred to the newly created Department of Homeland Security as part of a broader effort to streamline and enhance national security and emergency management after the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks.
“So at that time, FEMA had been moved under the Department of Homeland Security, and the Department of Homeland Security became much more terrorism-oriented, much more infrastructure-oriented. And FEMA was sort of demoted, kind of within that structure,” Schlegelmilch said.
Dr. Samantha Montano, assistant professor of emergency management at the Massachusetts Maritime Academy, was also critical of Project 2025’s proposals for FEMA.
“There is nothing in Project 2025 that aligns with the policy recommendations that come out of the empirical research that we have on what makes emergency management effective,” Montano told us in a phone interview.
“So currently, it’s within DHS, which is not effective, and moving it to another agency, whether it’s [the Department of] Inside or the Division of Transportation, wouldn’t clear up the issue. It might simply shuffle it into one other company,” Montano mentioned. “It’s the perception of many in emergency administration that FEMA is best when it’s an unbiased cabinet-level company.”
Concerning Venture 2025’s proposal on shifting most of FEMA’s preparedness and response prices to the states, Montano mentioned, “I feel this is able to be completely devastating, particularly for small, poorer communities and states. The overwhelming majority of states wouldn’t have the sources to fund their very own responses and recoveries.”
Editor’s observe: FactCheck.org is one in all a number of organizations working with Facebook to debunk misinformation shared on social media. Our earlier tales will be discovered here. Fb has no control over our editorial content material.
Sources
Congressional Price range Workplace. “FEMA’s Disaster Relief Fund: Budgetary History and Projections.” November 2022.
Contorno, Steve. “Trump claims not to know who is behind Project 2025. A CNN review found at least 140 people who worked for him are involved.” CNN. 11 Jul 2024.
Czachor, Emily Mae. “Hurricane Milton makes landfall as Category 3 on Florida’s west coast.” CBS Information. 10 Oct 2024.
Federal Emergency Administration Company. “Federal Assistance for Hurricane Helene Exceeds $344 Million as FEMA Expands Dual Response Efforts as Hurricane Milton Forecast to Make Landfall This Evening.” 9 Oct 2024.
Federal Emergency Administration Company. “Disaster Relief Fund: Monthly Report.” 13 Sep 2019.
Federal Emergency Administration Company. “FEMA Assistance Tops $1 Billion for Florida Hurricane Irma Survivors.” 19 Apr 2018.
Federal Emergency Administration Company. “Historic Disaster Response to Hurricane Harvey in Texas.” 22 Sep 2017.
Federal Emergency Administration Company. “History of FEMA.” 4 Jan 2021.
Federal Emergency Administration Company. “Hurricane Helene: Rumor Response.” 4 Oct 2024.
Federal Emergency Administration Company. “Coronavirus Rumor Control.” Up to date 15 Might 2023.
Federal Emergency Administration Company. “President Donald J. Trump Approves Major Disaster Declaration for Hawaii.” Press launch. 28 Sep 2018.
Flaherty, Anne and Stephanie Ebbs. “Trump to tap FEMA account to step up migrant deportations, House Dems say no way.” ABC Information. 28 Aug 2019.
Gore, D’Angelo. “Trump’s False Claim of Stolen Disaster Relief Funds.” FactCheck.org. 8 Oct 2024.
Hoffman, Riley. “Harris-Trump presidential debate transcript.” ABC Information. 10 Sep 2024.
Keefe, Eliza. “Posts Misrepresent Federal Response, Funding for Hurricane Helene Victims.” FactCheck.org. 8 Oct 2024.
Kiely, Eugene, D’Angelo Gore and Robert Farley. “A Guide to Project 2025.” FactCheck.org. 10 Sep 2024.
Leavitt, Karoline. Spokesperson, Donald J. Trump for President 2024. E mail to FactCheck.org. 9 Oct 2024.
Montano, Samantha. Assistant professor of emergency administration, Massachusetts Maritime Academy. Cellphone interview with FactCheck.org. 7 Oct 2024.
Nationwide Climate Service Forecast Workplace, Tampa Bay Space, Florida. “Key Messages for Hurricane Milton.” 8 Oct 2024.
Venture 2025. “Mandate for Leadership: The Conservative Promise.” Accessed 8 Oct 2024.
Sanchez, Ray. “‘The power of water.’ How Helene devastated western North Carolina and left communities in ruins.” CNN. 6 Oct 2024
Schlegelmilch, Jeffrey. Director, Nationwide Middle for Catastrophe Preparedness, Columbia Local weather Faculty. Cellphone interview with FactCheck.org. 7 Oct 2024.
Trump, Donald. “Western North Carolina, and the whole state, for that matter, has been totally and incompetently mismanaged by Harris/Biden. They can’t get anything done properly, but I will make up for lost time, and do it right, when I get there.” Reality Social. 9 Oct 2024.
White Home. “Hurricane Katrina: Lessons Learned.” Sep 2005.
White Home. “Press Gaggle by Press Secretary Karine Jean-Pierre and Secretary of Homeland Security Alejandro Mayorkas En Route Greenville, SC.” 2 Oct 2024.
