Ought to the Penguins commerce Lars Eller?

For the primary time in a number of years, the Pittsburgh Penguins are going into coaching camp with a plethora of centermen.

Earlier this summer season, they acquired veteran Kevin Hayes from the St. Louis Blues. They signed Blake Lizotte, previously of the Los Angeles Kings, to a two-year deal after the onset of free company. Then, in early August, they acquired Cody Glass, a former first-round draft choice in 2017, from the Nashville Predators.

The Penguins’ high two facilities – as they have been for the previous 18 years – are set in stone. So the place does this go away the 2 different facilities – Lars Eller and Noel Acciari – on the roster?

Acciari spent an excellent chunk of the 2023-24 season injured, and within the video games that he did play, he was good defensively however underwhelming on the offensive aspect of the puck. He has two years left on a three-year, $6 million contract he signed with the Penguins final summer season, and – at this juncture – it is unlikely that Pittsburgh would fetch a good return for him.

Then, there’s Eller. There are causes for him to go, and simply as many for him to remain.

Why he must be traded

The first cause Eller must be dealt is pretty easy: It is simply good enterprise.

Apart from top-four defenseman Marcus Pettersson – one other pending UFA subsequent season – Eller is the crew’s most dear commerce asset. At 35 years previous and after registering a good 15 goals and 31 points because the Penguins’ third-line middle, he is a lovely and helpful veteran middle possibility for contending groups trying to shore up their bottom-six.

Because the season progresses – even when he places up numbers much like final season’s – his commerce worth will lower as he grows nearer to unrestricted free company. Plus, at 35, it is arduous to say if numbers and well being will maintain up. So, there could also be no higher time to deal Eller than proper now, after they can virtually certainly get an honest choose (and maybe one other mid-late rounder) for him.

As well as – as reiterated a number of occasions over – the Penguins now have middle depth to spare. They’ve just a few kids like Rutger McGroarty, Valtteri Puustinen, and Vasily Ponomarev (one other middle prospect) who will likely be preventing a tricky battle for roster spots.

Though it might be good to maintain Eller round, buying and selling him now makes plenty of sense.

Why he ought to keep

Despite the fact that it seemingly is sensible to commerce Eller – particularly given GM and POHO Kyle Dubas’s need to stockpile draft capital – plenty of that form of hinges on whether or not or not the group believes it has constructed an NHL roster that’s able to competing this season.

Previous to the McGroarty commerce, that appeared like wishful considering to some. However for the reason that Penguins will, greater than possible, have one among hockey’s greatest prospects on their NHL roster sooner or later this season – and given all of their different strikes – it stands to cause that they consider they’re in place to battle for a playoff spot.

If that is the case, having a man like Eller round to middle the fourth line is nice insurance coverage, and it is a testomony to the truth that the bottom-six is definitely deeper than it has been in a number of years. Between he and Hayes, they will middle youthful forwards with vitality and a few offensive upside, and the Penguins might find yourself having a reasonably respectable ahead lineup alongside the strains of:

Drew O’Connor – Sidney Crosby – Bryan Rust

Michael Bunting – Evgeni Malkin – Rickard Rakell

Rutger McGroarty – Kevin Hayes – Cody Glass

Blake Lizotte – Lars Eller – Noel Acciari

Additional Forwards: Valtteri Puustinen, Anthony Beauvillier

That lineup seems to be rather a lot higher with Eller in it. So, if the Penguins really feel they will compete this season, they will at all times – like they’re, presumably, doing with the Pettersson state of affairs – wait out any Eller commerce speak to see how the season performs out.

There is not any right reply for this state of affairs. Nonetheless, it is going to be attention-grabbing to see how all the pieces unfolds over the approaching weeks.

Related: Where does Rutger McGroarty fit in the Penguins’ lineup?

Related: Three Penguins Most Likely to Be Traded Before Opening Night

Related: Five reasons to be optimistic about the Penguins in 2024-25