Este artículo estará disponible en español en El Tiempo Latino.
Lower than a month after we wrote a few deceptive advert that used out-of-context quotes to assault Vice President Kamala Harris on taxes, former President Donald Trump’s marketing campaign has launched one other anti-Harris advert drawing from the identical misleading political playbook. This time, the marketing campaign used distorted quotes from information shops to criticize Harris on taxes, unlawful immigration and different points.
For instance, the advert shortens a CBS News headline from “Harris vows to maintain Biden’s border crackdown” to “Harris vows to maintain Biden’s border.” The advert additionally cites NBC Information whereas making a declare about Harris offering “welfare for illegals,” although that clipped quote comes from a 6-year-old opinion piece that by no means talked about Harris.
As well as, the advert reuses a truncated line from a New York Times article to falsely counsel that Harris seeks “to considerably increase taxes” on all Individuals, when the newspaper mentioned that her plan focuses on rising taxes for very rich people and firms — not individuals making lower than $400,000 a yr. That’s the identical edited quote we wrote about in early October.
Trump’s marketing campaign started operating the brand new 1-minute advert in a number of states on Oct. 27, in response to political advert monitoring service AdImpact. A 30-second version, with solely a few of the deceptive quotes, started airing on Oct. 30, and a version in Spanish began operating on Nov. 1.
Taxes
Whereas the advert’s narrator says that President Joe Biden and Harris “raised taxes on the center class,” textual content on display screen says that “Harris is looking for to considerably increase taxes” — a quote that’s attributed to the New York Occasions. However that Aug. 22 article didn’t say that the Biden administration raised taxes on middle-income Individuals, nor did it say that Harris needs to boost taxes for all earnings teams, because the advert’s partial Occasions quote suggests.
What the Occasions reported was: “Nobody making lower than $400,000 a yr would see their taxes go up underneath the plan. As an alternative, Ms. Harris is looking for to considerably increase taxes on the wealthiest Individuals and huge firms.” (See pictures under.)
As we’ve written, Harris’ financial coverage ebook says she “will be sure that nobody incomes lower than $400,000 a yr pays extra in taxes” and can “roll again Trump’s tax cuts for the richest Individuals.”
Harris proposes elevating the company tax fee from 21% to twenty-eight%; restoring the highest particular person earnings tax fee to 39.6% from 37%, which now applies to earnings above roughly $609,000 for people and $731,000 for married {couples}; rising the long-term capital beneficial properties fee to twenty-eight% from 20% for households with annual taxable earnings of greater than $1 million; and taxing unrealized capital beneficial properties at demise for beneficial properties above $5 million for people and $10 million for joint filers. She additionally has mentioned she would remove taxes on ideas for service and hospitality staff, and increase the kid tax credit score, together with a $6,000 credit score for newborns.
The Border
The narrator goes on to say that “Kamala was in control of his open border insurance policies,” whereas a graphic quotes CBS Information as saying, “Harris Vows to Hold Biden’s Border.”
First, Biden doesn’t have an open border coverage, and he didn’t put Harris in control of points on the U.S. border with Mexico, which is the job of the Division of Homeland Safety secretary, as we’ve reported. Harris had a extra restricted position as the lead on the “Root Causes Technique,” an effort to “enhance safety, governance, human rights, and financial situations” in Central American nations. The technique included quite a lot of actions designed to “handle the basis causes of migration” from El Salvador, Guatemala and Honduras, particularly.
Second, the complete headline of the Sept. 28 CBS News article cited within the advert mentioned: “Harris vows to maintain Biden’s border crackdown: ‘The US is a sovereign nation.’” (See the pictures under.)
Opposite to the advert’s suggestion that Harris would embrace “open border insurance policies” as president, the CBS Information article went on to say that, throughout her late September go to to a part of the border in Arizona, Harris pledged to maintain “Biden’s asylum crackdown in place if elected, solidifying Democrats’ embrace of extra stringent immigration guidelines.”
Migrant Advantages
Because the narrator means that Biden and Harris are “giving welfare to illegals,” textual content proven on display screen, and attributed to NBC Information, says “welfare for illegals.” However these three phrases had been taken from an extended sentence in a March 28, 2018, opinion piece revealed nearly three years earlier than Biden and Harris took workplace in January 2021. The NBC Information piece, which didn’t point out Biden or Harris, was about how “welfare reform” legal guidelines handed throughout Invoice Clinton’s administration can forestall recipients of Deferred Motion for Childhood Arrivals from acquiring skilled or industrial licenses wanted to get sure jobs.
“No matter one’s place on welfare for unlawful immigrants, a license is clearly totally different from meals stamps and different authorities security nets,” the writer wrote.
The opinion article famous {that a} regulation that Clinton signed in 1996 prevents “unauthorized immigrants from receiving quite a few ‘public advantages,’ until a state enacts a regulation that explicitly makes unauthorized immigrants eligible.”
On her campaign website, Harris says that she does assist “an earned pathway to citizenship” for individuals illegally within the nation, which might finally make a minimum of some eligible to obtain advantages from federal funded applications. However Harris doesn’t present particulars on such a plan, and it’s unclear if it might have adequate assist in Congress to grow to be regulation.
World Conflicts
The narrator additionally blames Biden and Harris for the state of worldwide affairs, claiming that “their weak spot invited wars.” Because the narrator speaks, the phrases “International Struggle” seem on display screen and are attributed to the information web site Axios.
However the full headline of that July 31 article mentioned, “U.S. not prepared for world battle, fee warns.” The story was a few 100-plus web page report from Congress’ Fee on the Nationwide Protection Technique that detailed why the U.S. shouldn’t be ready for a possible battle with Russia and Ukraine. Axios didn’t fault the Biden administration for ongoing abroad wars, because the advert could lead on viewers to consider.
Harris has called for a ceasefire deal, and the discharge of hostages, to finish the battle in Gaza. The vice chairman additionally has said that, as president, she “will stand sturdy with Ukraine and our NATO allies” amid Ukraine’s battle with Russia.
Harris’ Agenda
Lastly, the narrator claims that “Kamala needs to double down on failure,” whereas textual content on the display screen says, “Kamala’s Insurance policies ‘Could be the identical as Biden’s.’” The advert attributes the road about Harris’ insurance policies to an Oct. 14 Hill story, however the newspaper didn’t say Harris would mirror Biden as president.
As an alternative, the newspaper was paraphrasing one thing mentioned by political commentator Chris Matthews. The headline of the Hill article reads: “Chris Matthews: ‘Large mistake’ for Harris to say insurance policies can be the identical as Biden’s.”
The story was about feedback Matthews made after Harris’ Oct. 8 appearance on ABC’s “The View,” during which Harris mentioned “not a factor that involves thoughts” when she was requested if she would have performed something in a different way than Biden within the final 4 years. “I believe when she says her insurance policies are going to be the identical as Biden’s, that’s an enormous mistake,” Matthews mentioned throughout an Oct. 14 appearance on MSNBC.
Nonetheless, Harris didn’t say that she would have the very same insurance policies as Biden if she turns into president. Her touch upon “The View” was in regards to the previous, not the long run.
She does assist the continuation of many Biden insurance policies, such because the pledge to not increase taxes for individuals making underneath $400,000. However she additionally has proposed new insurance policies, together with a plan to supply eligible first-time homebuyers with as much as $25,000 in mortgage help.
In an Oct. 20 campaign speech from the Ellipse in Washington, D.C., Harris mentioned: “I’ve been honored to function Joe Biden’s vice chairman, however I’ll carry my very own experiences and concepts to the Oval Workplace. My presidency will probably be totally different as a result of the challenges we face are totally different.”
Editor’s observe: FactCheck.org doesn’t settle for promoting. We depend on grants and particular person donations from individuals such as you. Please contemplate a donation. Bank card donations could also be made by means of our “Donate” page. When you choose to offer by test, ship to: FactCheck.org, Annenberg Public Coverage Middle, 202 S. thirty sixth St., Philadelphia, PA 19104.
