‘It was a nightmare. It nonetheless is’: the price of doing enterprise, eight years after Brexit

Precisely eight years in the past, the UK went to the polls and voted to go away the EU.

Ending a union that had begun in 1973, the choice was certain to have a profound affect on companies each within the UK and on the continent.

The exit from the only market – which ensured the free motion of products, providers and other people between the UK and EU – in 2021 has hit all facets of trade, from commerce to hiring staff.

A report simply final week by the Centre for Economic Performance concluded that Brexit had had a negative effect on UK trade, with exports and imports decrease than they had been in 2016 in actual phrases, having shrunk by 1% and a pair of% respectively.

Based on the report, commerce with the EU has declined lower than many economists anticipated general, and a few sectors of the UK economic system, akin to providers, have continued to achieve success. Nevertheless, many different enterprise sectors haven’t fared as effectively. Whether it is UK clothing exports dropping by a fifth since 2019, or the 56% fall in poultry exports, many sectors are nonetheless adjusting to a life exterior the EU.

The tail of Brexit continues to wag, as new border checks since April have led to fears of more disruption, with estimates putting the cost to businesses bringing in food and plant products at £2bn. And the reverberations are nonetheless being felt by companies massive and small.

To mark the eighth anniversary of the referendum, the Observer spoke to 6 firms within the UK and the EU to see how Brexit has affected their enterprise.

‘There are actually 50 extra steps’

Royal Lemkes, plant exporter, Bleiswijk, the Netherlands

“There are actually about 50 extra steps that we’ve got to take now on exports in contrast with earlier than Brexit,” says Maurits Philippo, enterprise unit supervisor at Dutch flower exporter Royal Lemkes.

The corporate relies in Bleiswijk, and sources and transports crops to Ikea and B&Q within the UK. Its subsidiary Floréac provides smaller impartial backyard centres throughout Britain.

The corporate, which has a turnover of €275m, exports to 31 international locations, however the choice by its third greatest overseas market to go away the EU has resulted in vital modifications to its operations.

Philippo says that earlier than Brexit the one actual distinction between buying and selling with the UK and different EU international locations was the change charge. Now, the method consists of customs declaration varieties, plant well being certificates and practically 50 different extra post-Brexit actions.

“We needed to make modifications in our IT system, and introduced in two additional workers simply to work on simply exports to Britain,” he says. It additionally now leases its personal distribution centre in East Yorkshire due to Brexit.

Royal Lemkes determined to proceed supplying the UK. Others merely gave up. “Plenty of smaller export firms, the place solely a small proportion of commerce went to Britain, stopped supplying,” says Philippo. “They stated, ‘this seems to be too troublesome, this may by no means work, we are going to deal with our French or German clients’.”

For Philippo, the additional prices are essentially the most vital affect for importers. And these prices elevated additional on 30 April with the introduction of new border checks on many plant and animal products coming into Britain from the continent. Beneath the brand new guidelines, some hundreds are despatched to frame posts alongside the coast, with firms charged for the method. Typically, the posts can have completely different charging buildings.

“This makes it troublesome to know what the ultimate cost can be, and finally these will go onto our value costs and eventually on to the [British] shopper,” he says.

He provides that some Dutch exporters are reporting cases of crops being broken or delayed throughout the checks at these posts, leading to misplaced income.

“With these new checks, firms are saying it’s too difficult, and after a number of years’ buying and selling with the UK, they’re stopping,” he says.

‘Brexit has made us busy’

MDDP, authorized agency, Warsaw, Poland

Whereas it could have been bought by some as a manner of slicing pink tape, Britain’s exit from the only market has offered quite a few new guidelines for exports and imports.

This has led to an elevated demand for legal professionals and customs brokers to assist confused companies navigate the brand new panorama.

“Brexit has made us actually busy,” says Agnieszka Kisielewska, worldwide commerce and tax accomplice at Warsaw-based legislation agency MDDP.

In 2020, the enterprise noticed the variety of clients searching for commerce recommendation double. In 2021, the variety of clients greater than doubled once more, and MDDP needed to improve its commerce crew by 1 / 4.

The most effective recognized tax advisers in Poland, the agency’s enlargement has coincided with a increase in Polish commerce with the UK since Brexit. Total bilateral trade hit £31.2bn in 2023, up 28% on 2019, whereas the worth of imports reached £20.5bn, up greater than 29% from 4 years earlier.

Kisielewska says this development has additionally led to extra Polish companies searching for recommendation on tips on how to arrange warehouses within the UK.

“Polish firms need to hold clients within the UK as completely happy as they had been earlier than Brexit, and one of many options has been to arrange warehouses to allow them to provide clients extra shortly,” she says.

The brand new customs guidelines, excise responsibility and VAT laws have led to some struggles, however she believes Poland’s location on the sting of the EU and expertise of commerce with non-EU nations have left it extra ready than another international locations.

“We’re used to exporting exterior the EU and have solely been within the union for 20 years, so most firms have data of life earlier than the EU,” Kisielewska says.

‘Vastly costly’

Wack’s Depraved Vegetation, carnivorous plant dealer, Yorkshire, England

When Peter and Helleentje Walker had been getting ready for the Chelsea flower present final yr, they had been quietly assured, having beforehand received three gold medals on the occasion.

Nevertheless, simply weeks earlier than they had been to journey all the way down to London from their base in Scampston, they had been pressured to tug out attributable to Brexit guidelines. “The brand new guidelines meant we couldn’t pay money for crops we wanted,” he says.

After assembly within the Netherlands within the Eighties, the Walkers started their Wack’s Depraved Plant enterprise, which specialises in carnivorous crops, with only one polytunnel 12 years in the past. At present, they’ve six. Earlier than the Brexit vote, that they had steadily elevated exports and begun constructing a popularity throughout the EU. Since leaving the only market, they haven’t exported something.

“Earlier than, you simply wanted a plant passport and that was it. Now you want [phytosanitary] inspections which might be massively costly,” says Peter.

“If we’ve got a buyer from Spain who needs 5 crops for £70, it may cost £80 for the inspection – no person goes to pay that,” provides Helleentje.

However the greatest headache for the Walkers has been new boundaries for bringing in crops. Most of their inventory begins life in Europe as younger crops earlier than being grown of their polytunnels. Many are protected underneath the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (Cites). Earlier than Brexit, no paperwork or checks had been wanted to deliver Cites crops to Britain from the EU.

“Swiftly, sarracenias and Venus flytraps, our two bestselling crops, wanted licences and permits earlier than they could possibly be introduced in,” Peter says, referring to when Cites controls had been applied final yr.

skip past newsletter promotion

after publication promotion

Since then, they are saying, they’ve been “banging their heads in opposition to the wall” for 15 months with the authorities, typically ready as much as six weeks for the appropriate documentation for deliveries. This got here to a head final Could after they needed to pull out of Chelsea due to Cites points.

“I’ve by no means skilled something as annoying as what occurred when Cites got here in,” Peter says. “It was an absolute nightmare. It nonetheless is.”

‘We dumped our UK provider’

Denroy, producer, Bangor, Northern Eire

There are only a few firms that may checklist parts for Storm jet fighters and salon-standard hair brushes within the vary of merchandise they manufacture. Northern Irish firm Denroy can do exactly that.

Based greater than 50 years in the past in Bangor as an injection moulding firm, its Denman brush shot to fame within the Sixties after Vidal Sassoon declared it the proper brush for blowdrying hair.

Since then, 3m Denman brushes have been bought globally and the £30m turnover firm has diversified to produce wing parts for Airbus and Bombardier, amongst different issues. It’s assured that it may well double its turnover in 4 years.

Beneath the Northern Eire protocol, says Kevin McNamee, Denroy’s chief government, “we actually have the very best of each worlds. We’ve got free, unencumbered motion of merchandise manufactured to EU requirements into any EU nation, whereas additionally being assured unfettered entry into Nice Britain.”

He provides that, whereas politicians don’t wish to say it publicly, Northern Irish firms have a “aggressive benefit” over these in Nice Britain in relation to commerce.

For items coming to Northern Eire from Nice Britain, paperwork should nonetheless be supplied to indicate they adjust to EU legal guidelines, and received’t journey past Northern Eire.

The Brexit fallout has induced different issues for British companies that need to ship merchandise to Northern Eire. Merchandise manufactured within the UK will be exported to Northern Eire and the EU with zero tariffs, underneath the UK-EU commerce and cooperation settlement. Nevertheless, EU guidelines of origin laws imply that merchandise being despatched from the UK which have originated exterior the UK or EU could possibly be topic to tariffs.

This may make it much less enticing for some Northern Irish companies to commerce with Nice Britain over EU international locations the place the tariffs don’t apply.

“Within the yr or so after Brexit, we paid tens of hundreds of kilos on tariffs,” he says. “In some instances, we merely re-sourced the availability, so sadly the GB provider acquired dumped and we went on to the EU to keep away from tariffs.”

‘Customs now not applies’

Kingsland Drinks, wine bottler, Larger Manchester, England

On the outskirts of Manchester, subsequent to the ship canal in Irlam, sits the Kingsland Drinks bottling plant.

Using about 450 individuals, Kingsland’s predominant enterprise is importing large 24,000-litre baggage of wine from throughout the globe, bottling it, and transport it to supermarkets and retailers. Roughly 80% of the wine it receives comes from the New World areas, with the vast majority of that from Australia and New Zealand.

With a lot of its enterprise centered on these markets, it has seen some tangible advantages of commerce offers with the 2 international locations since Brexit. The offers, struck in December 2021, eliminated tariffs on all items, and had been bought as an enormous post-Brexit bonus.

“Our clients and the tip customers have seen the advantages, as a result of EU frequent customs utilized on wines from each international locations and now they don’t,” says Ed Baker, the managing director at Kingsland.

The corporate expects to save lots of about £1.1m in customs responsibility on the wine it imports from New Zealand within the first yr of the offers, and £3.2m from Australian imports.

However whereas Brexit has lowered prices for customers with one hand, it has heaped on prices with the opposite.

The brand new post-Brexit alcohol responsibility regime noticed excise responsibility on most bottles of wine improve by 44p in August final yr. “For an Australian wine you would possibly lose between 7.5p and 9p on the removing of tariffs however you’ll be paying 44p extra on excise responsibility, and that’s ignoring the additional VAT too,” says Baker.

These guidelines can be altered once more from February 2025 when the quantity of responsibility paid on every bottle of wine rises even additional, up by 2p for each 0.1% improve in power. Because of this bottles of wine with the very best alcohol by quantity might see an additional 43p added subsequent yr.

‘This has scuppered it’

Amber Violins, musical ­instrument dealer, Gloucestershire, England

As a dealer in secondhand violins, cellos and bows, Amber Violins is reliant on the EU for each sourcing and promoting items.

Earlier than Brexit, its proprietor and solely full-time workers member, Matthew Gryspeerdt, used to journey often to France to sellers the place he would decide up the devices and convey them again to public sale on his web site.

Earlier than Brexit, importers solely needed to pay VAT on the margin of the sale, however since Brexit the whole lot imported, even when secondhand, is charged at full VAT.

“So if I purchase for £100 I’ve acquired to promote for £120 earlier than I begin to make something myself – in order that margin, which was my revenue margin, that has disappeared,” he says.

“I had developed the enterprise to a stage the place I used to be placing them onto the public sale web site and promoting round 1,000 models a yr,” says Gryspeerdt. Since Brexit, the web site has gone, with the variety of devices bought annually all the way down to about 40.

“I now focus much more on the higher-value and dearer objects to chop down on the forms,” he says. “Brexit utterly scuppered it, actually. I principally couldn’t deliver stuff in and not using a transport agent, and that wasn’t possible for a small enterprise like mine.”