Fast Take
Crime statistics compiled by the FBI and different sources present a rise in violent crime, notably murders, in 2020 and a decline since. A revision to the FBI knowledge this yr doesn’t change that general pattern, regardless of claims made on social media and by the Trump marketing campaign on the contrary.
Full Story
Native regulation enforcement businesses voluntarily report crime knowledge to the FBI, which compiles the figures in annual stories on crime nationwide, with some estimation accomplished when businesses don’t report figures for a full yr, or in any respect. The annual figures for 2023, released last month, present a decline in violent crime since 2020 — the final yr of former President Donald Trump’s administration.
In 2020, the primary yr of the COVID-19 pandemic, there was a spike in violent crime general, as a consequence of will increase in murders and aggravated assaults. Consultants have said that the pandemic, and its financial repercussions, was one issue behind the rise. Violent crime has eased again down since then.
The quantity and fee per 100,000 inhabitants for violent crime general, in addition to for homicide and nonnegligent manslaughter, rape, theft and aggravated assault, all went down from 2020 to 2023, in line with the FBI-compiled statistics. The violent crime fee dropped by 22.5 factors, the homicide fee declined by 0.9 factors. The variety of murders decreased by 14.5%. (For these figures, see the Crime in america Annual Stories here and obtain the CIUS Estimations file for 2023. See Desk 1.)
As we have reported, different sources of crime stats present the identical pattern. The Main Cities Chiefs Affiliation stories, with the addition of New York City’s statistics, show a 9.1% lower within the variety of murders in 70 giant U.S. cities from 2020 to 2023, and a further decline for the primary half of 2024. As of early this month, AH Datalytics, an unbiased felony justice knowledge evaluation group, reported a 17.9% lower in murders in additional than 250 U.S. cities to this point this yr, in contrast with the identical factors in 2023.
“Violent crime rose in 2020 and has fallen since then although the rise in violent crime has at all times been extra muted than folks assume. Homicide, against this, rose a ton in 2020 and is falling a ton proper now,” Jeff Asher, co-founder of AH Datalytics, not too long ago wrote in a Substack put up.
Regardless of these traits, Trump and different Republicans have wrongly claimed all through the marketing campaign that violent crime has gone up underneath President Joe Biden. Trump has even claimed that the FBI statistics are “faux.”
Now, the marketing campaign has seized on a yearly revision of the FBI figures. Revisions are routinely done yearly, however this yr’s have been notable as a result of they flipped what was a decline in violent crime from 2021 to 2022 in final yr’s report back to a rise. (Adam Gelb, president and CEO of the unbiased Council on Prison Justice, advised us this could occur with revisions, notably when coping with “low single-digit share level modifications.”)
The Trump marketing campaign says the revision is proof that Trump was “proper,” and social media posts are falsely claiming the FBI knowledge now reveal that crime has “skyrocketed” or “gone via the ROOF” underneath Biden.
Even with the revisions, nevertheless, the 2022 — and 2023 — figures for violent crime, and homicide particularly, are decrease than the figures for 2020.
At an Oct. 20 rally in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, Trump took difficulty with ABC Information fact-checking him throughout the debate with Vice President Kamala Harris when Trump claimed that “crime on this nation is thru the roof.” ABC Information moderator David Muir countered, “As you realize, the FBI says general violent crime is definitely coming down on this nation.”
In Lancaster, Trump wrongly said, “No, no crime is means up. And the FBI, we have now to have a look at this as a result of the FBI put out charts that crime was down initially as a result of they didn’t report sure little areas of the nation just like the worst areas within the nation for crime, and it turned out that their stats have been very improper and really deceptive. However he [Muir] was improper as a result of it was — it’s up like not less than 45%.”
Muir wasn’t — and isn’t — improper, although. The revised FBI figures nonetheless present that general violent crime has come down since 2020, Trump’s final yr in workplace. They usually under no circumstances present that crime is up 45%. (Trump typically cites the Nationwide Crime Victimization Survey, a survey that asks folks whether or not they had been victims of varied crimes, although we didn’t see his 45% determine there. The survey has its personal limitations, and it doesn’t measure homicide, as we’ve explained.)
Trump’s description of how the FBI figures have been revised can be off.
Revised Crime Figures
Right here’s a comparability of the FBI figures reported final yr and the revised figures launched final month. Because the charts present, whereas the revisions elevated the speed of violent crime (and homicide) in 2022, there was an excellent bigger downward revision to the 2021 figures.
One social media put up claimed that the FBI “discovered” 1,699 extra murders in 2022, however that’s not the case. The FBI revised the variety of murders in 2022 upward by 625, and it revised the 2021 complete downward by 1,074.
There’s additionally purpose to doubt, or not learn an excessive amount of into, the 2021 numbers, which, as a consequence of a change in methodology, needed to be estimated much more than standard. That’s the yr that had the issue Trump alluded to — fewer regulation enforcement businesses reporting figures. However the difficulty is exclusive to 2021.
Asher advised us in a telephone interview that the revised 2021 numbers are probably an undercount. AH Datalytics and different crime knowledge sources discovered a slight improve in murders in 2021 from 2020, so it “doesn’t make plenty of sense” to see a lower within the newest revision, he mentioned.
As we’ve explained before, the FBI has been transitioning to a brand new system for knowledge assortment, and in 2021, it required native regulation enforcement businesses to make use of what’s referred to as the National Incident-Based Reporting System. However at the moment, many police departments, together with these in New York and Los Angeles, hadn’t switched to NIBRS, so that they weren’t included within the uncooked 2021 statistics. When releasing the 2021 figures initially, the FBI and the Bureau of Justice Statistics offered nationwide estimates for 2021, however they have been based mostly on knowledge that lined solely about 65% of the inhabitants.
Earlier than then — and after 2021 — the info reported by regulation enforcement businesses lined 90% or extra of the inhabitants. For 2022 and 2023, participation in NIBRS elevated, and the FBI also has accepted knowledge submitted via the older system for businesses that haven’t made the change. So, the low-reporting downside in 2021 is remoted to that yr.
The most recent annual figures for 2023 have been based mostly on knowledge overlaying 94.3% of the U.S. inhabitants, whereas 2020 and 2022 figures have been based mostly on knowledge overlaying 97% and 95% of the inhabitants, respectively, as proven in a chart Asher printed in an Oct. 21 Substack post.
Regardless of subsequent revisions to the 2021 numbers, they’re nonetheless unsure. The stories from regulation enforcement businesses for that yr now cowl solely 74.1% of the inhabitants.
“Regular ranges of participation in 2020, 2022 and 2023 assist paint a narrative of US crime traits that doesn’t depend on the defective 2021 knowledge,” Asher wrote. “The 2021 estimates have been deeply flawed and will largely be ignored. That was true in 2022, it was true in 2023, and it’s true in 2024.”
“I’d really feel happier if everybody simply ignored” the 2021 figures, Asher advised us, calling that yr’s complete a “unhealthy” estimate.
The FBI despatched us an announcement explaining how the 2021 figures have been estimated since they have been first launched. It mentioned, as we defined, that due to a “decrease quantity of participation, the FBI was unable to supply the normal nationwide estimates for 2021.” To offer a comparability of crime traits, it had carried out an “estimation crime pattern evaluation” for the figures the FBI initially printed.
The next yr, when it launched the 2022 statistics, the 2021 figures included “a statistical sampling of 2021 knowledge to enhance the 2021 data collected by way of NIBRS.” Then, with the discharge of the 2023 report this yr, the FBI revised the 2021 figures to “mirror solely estimates based mostly on the info immediately reported to the FBI. This explains why the determine seems completely different than the computed estimation printed within the Crime within the Nation, 2022.”
The FBI mentioned that the Crime within the Nation 2023 report “was the primary part within the FBI’s efforts to supply the general public with extra well timed knowledge. The following part will see a shift to month-to-month knowledge releases to advertise transparency and supply a chance for shoppers to assessment knowledge based mostly on extra well timed crime counts with the understanding that knowledge will likely be constantly up to date. As a part of this motion, the FBI has moved in the direction of automation, permitting for previous years’ estimates to be up to date as knowledge are submitted.”
Some feedback by the Trump marketing campaign might depart the impression that the FBI had accomplished one thing dishonest. Asher and Gelb mentioned there is no such thing as a proof of something like that.
In a marketing campaign e-mail, the Trump marketing campaign mentioned: “A brand new report reveals the FBI secretly up to date its crime knowledge to indicate that violent crime didn’t drop by 2.1% in 2022, however as a substitute elevated in 2022 by 4.5%,” pointing to a report in RealClearInvestigations, which had highlighted the FBI revisions, calling them a “stealth edit” that the FBI didn’t point out in its press launch about its report.
Sen. JD Vance, Trump’s vice presidential working mate, said in a speech in North Carolina on Oct. 16 that the FBI “simply launched some up to date crime numbers which urged crime was greater than they beforehand let on in 2022. I’m shocked by that.”
It’s true that the FBI’s press launch on its newest report didn’t point out the revisions — however such revisions are incessantly made, Asher noted, and press releases aren’t despatched out concerning the methodology.
Gelb advised us that the FBI “might’ve dealt with this a lot better” and “the best way that it’s enjoying out does undermine public confidence.” However “there’s no proof of any political interference from the administration. None in anyway. The FBI aggregates these numbers which are equipped by state and native regulation enforcement.” He’s “not conscious of a single company that mentioned, ‘Hey they garbled our numbers.’”
He mentioned the Council on Prison Justice has discovered an analogous sample of crime since 2019. “Violent crimes elevated, notably murder, throughout the first couple years of the pandemic,” he mentioned, after which have been lowering again to the pre-pandemic ranges. The other occurred with property crimes. They went down early within the pandemic, as folks stayed residence extra and shops have been closed, making burglaries harder, after which property crimes returned as retailers opened and other people went again to work. An “sincere analysis,” Gelb mentioned, would “have a look at the broader pattern, not two years in center.”
“There’s no conspiracy, there’s no try to deceive, there aren’t unprecedented stealth modifications being out of the blue made, the FBI didn’t out of the blue ‘discover’ a ton of crime,” Asher wrote in his Oct. 21 Substack put up.
And regardless of the revisions, the general crime pattern hasn’t modified.
“We’ve acquired plenty of sources all pointing in the identical route,” Asher advised us. Even when the FBI figures for 2023, and 2024, are later revised up, “we’re nonetheless an unlimited lower in homicide.”
Editor’s word: FactCheck.org doesn’t settle for promoting. We depend on grants and particular person donations from folks such as you. Please contemplate a donation. Bank card donations could also be made via our “Donate” page. In the event you choose to offer by verify, ship to: FactCheck.org, Annenberg Public Coverage Middle, 202 S. thirty sixth St., Philadelphia, PA 19104.
