SciCheck Digest
Specialists say individuals can not create or meaningfully alter hurricanes via present climate modification strategies. That has not stopped a deluge of social media posts baselessly claiming or implying that Hurricanes Helene and Milton had been deliberately created, steered or in any other case managed by somebody.
Full Story
Hurricane Helene made landfall in Florida on Sept. 26, followed by Hurricane Milton on Oct. 9. Amid the deaths and destruction from the hurricanes, social media posts spread bogus claims that somebody had prompted or altered the storms by way of some climate modification method.
There’s a actual historical past of climate modification efforts, with some modest leads to producing snow and rain via a method referred to as cloud seeding. Nevertheless, it has by no means been proven to be doable to meaningfully modify hurricanes, neither is there any foundation for the concept somebody manipulated Hurricanes Helene or Milton.
“Hurricane Helene was NOT a ‘naturally occurring’ climate occasion,” mentioned some of the many baseless posts on the subject. “This occasion was fully MANIPULATED by man, & guided right into a sure course, for a sure purpose.”
Whereas many posts had been obscure about who had purportedly managed the hurricanes, others pointed a finger on the U.S. authorities.
“A hurricane as climate warfare,” learn one post. “If you wish to argue with me I’m joyful to bury you in patents, gov contracts and tax {dollars}. You’re looking at some of the horrific occasions ever perpetrated by our authorities by itself individuals.”
Claims about Helene then morphed into claims about Milton. “Hurricane Milton is focused geo-engineered storm getting used as a weapon,” wrote Stew Peters, an web character who has unfold quite a few conspiracy theories, in an X post.
Amongst these including gas to those claims was Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene, who unleashed a sequence of X posts implying purposeful modification of the storms. “Sure they’ll management the climate,” Greene posted on Oct. 3. “It’s ridiculous for anybody to lie and say it may possibly’t be completed.”
Greene, who’s a Republican from Georgia, which has been affected by the storms, didn’t clarify who “they” are or why somebody would wish to trigger a devastating hurricane. However earlier that day she had posted a map that has been connected to a declare that Hurricane Helene was focused to disproportionately have an effect on Republicans. Within the days since, as one other hurricane headed towards Florida, Greene continued to post about weather modification, doubling down on her suggestion. She has a history of spreading conspiracy theories and different misinformation, including about natural disasters.
Not solely is there zero proof that anybody tried to change the paths of the hurricanes, however it’s implausible that somebody might modify a hurricane, not to mention in such a strategy to goal particular teams.
“There is no such thing as a scientific proof that any climate modification has been profitable in hurricanes,” Katja Friedrich, who research cloud and precipitation formation and modification on the College of Colorado Boulder, advised us in an electronic mail.
President Joe Biden referenced Greene’s claims in an Oct. 9 press convention, saying the concept “we’re controlling the climate” is “past ridiculous.” He continued, “It’s received to cease. In moments like this, there aren’t any purple or blue states.”
Greene additionally made fun of people that have implicated local weather change within the hurricanes, ridiculing the concept “cow farts” might trigger them. Different social media posts additionally dismissed local weather change as a doable contributor to the hurricanes, claiming, as an illustration, that “[w]eather modification crimes [are] hiding behind the label of Local weather Change.”
However there’s a good case that local weather change made varied points of Hurricanes Helene and Milton worse, and it’s clear that local weather change will affect hurricane exercise over the approaching years. (Additionally for the report, methane emissions from livestock do contribute to local weather change, however the majority of the methane produced by cows is emitted by way of burps, not farts.)
“Local weather change didn’t trigger these storms to happen but it surely plausibly altered the chances of them reaching sure thresholds of depth, fast intensification, or rainfall charges, for instance,” Tom Knutson, a senior scientist on the Geophysical Fluid Dynamics Laboratory on the Nationwide Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, advised us in an electronic mail.
Hurricane Modification Claims Lack Any Foundation
Folks have a protracted historical past of attempting to vary the climate — not all of it well-intentioned — however the successes are restricted.
Many posts, together with some by Greene, mentioned or linked to sources referencing cloud seeding, the first methodology used for climate modification.
In some U.S. states and international locations, governments, utilities and firms pay for cloud seeding to boost the snowpack within the mountains or to extend rainfall in dry areas. The method depends on including small particles to clouds to stimulate ice crystals or droplets to kind, which might fall to the bottom as rain or snow. Within the U.S., ground-based machines or airplanes typically launch silver iodide, nudging close by clouds to launch snow.
There have been questions on how properly these packages work, since it may be arduous to inform whether or not rain or snow after these operations would have fallen anyway. Nevertheless, a 2018 study by Friedrich and her colleagues indicated that cloud seeding actually could cause snow to fall, though it’s unclear how a lot the method can improve snow in varied conditions.
The tactic will not be used to manage hurricanes. “There is no such thing as a method that these storms underwent cloud seeding,” Friedrich mentioned.
Cloud seeding wouldn’t change the observe of a climate system, she mentioned. She defined that the method “often focuses on enhancing precipitation in precipitating clouds (rain or snow) and in breaking apart massive hailstones into smaller ones in thunderstorms to make them much less impactful.” Nor have there been any experiments exhibiting “cloud seeding in hurricanes produce kind of precipitation,” she mentioned.
The U.S. authorities did try to make use of cloud seeding to mitigate hurricanes at varied factors starting within the Forties and ending in 1983 — a truth referenced by social media posts and in a Gateway Pundit article shared by Greene. However there isn’t proof these packages had been efficient at modifying hurricanes, and a few outcomes initially interpreted as successes didn’t pan out.
The U.S. authorities additionally tried to secretly use cloud seeding to create further rainfall and disrupt enemy provide chains through the Vietnam Battle, in the end resulting in a world treaty banning use of climate modification for army causes. This historical past was additionally referenced in latest posts on climate modification, though it’s not clear whether or not this operation met its meant objective.
Citing a 2013 interview with physicist Michio Kaku on CBS Information that has beforehand been misinterpreted, Greene additionally brought up the concept lasers might management the climate. However Jérôme Kasparian, a physicist on the College of Geneva who has researched utilizing lasers to extend rainfall and modify the trail of lightning, advised us that initiating and sustaining a hurricane utilizing lasers wouldn’t be doable. “You would wish to control quantities of power which can be fully past what you could possibly do,” he mentioned.
Furthermore, his personal analysis on climate modification utilizing lasers has been experimental, he mentioned, and isn’t prepared for routine use. “To the very best of my information essentially the most superior work on this course with lasers is ours,” Kasparian mentioned of his makes an attempt to nudge clouds to provide rain with lasers. “We’re removed from getting raindrops,” he mentioned, including that his efforts to information lightning with lasers additionally wants “loads of work and growth.”
Lastly, some posts referenced the Excessive-frequency Lively Auroral Analysis Program on the College of Alaska Fairbanks as a purported climate modification method. However HAARP is a primary science analysis program aimed at understanding the very best components of the ambiance utilizing radio waves. It has nothing to do with climate modification and couldn’t alter hurricanes.
“Radio waves within the frequency ranges that HAARP transmits are usually not absorbed in both the troposphere or the stratosphere—the 2 ranges of the ambiance that produce Earth’s climate,” says an FAQ web page on the HAARP web site. “Since there is no such thing as a interplay, there is no such thing as a strategy to management the climate.”
Local weather Change Is Actual, Can Have an effect on Hurricanes
Social media posts have additionally used the bogus claims about intentional climate modification as a chance to dismiss the fact of human-caused local weather change.
As now we have written many occasions, heat-trapping greenhouse gases produced by human actions have warmed the planet, resulting in a wide range of local weather results. The connection between local weather change and hurricanes is complex, however rising international temperatures have already got influenced and can proceed to affect Atlantic hurricanes.
Local weather change causes sea degree rise as hotter temperatures soften land ice and water warms and expands. Sea degree rise, in combination with extra coastal growth, will increase the danger of enormous storm surges and harm from hurricanes. Human-caused local weather change has already elevated sea ranges, and this has “very doubtless elevated the affect of hurricanes relative to the case with out sea degree rise,” Knutson, the NOAA scientist, advised us.
Local weather change can be anticipated to result in extra intense Atlantic hurricanes, that means hurricanes with higher wind speeds. And it has already boosted excessive rainfall, since hotter air holds extra moisture — and probably contributed to a rise in quickly intensifying hurricanes — though this isn’t sure. Knutson mentioned local weather change probably impacted Helene and Milton in every of those methods.
Up to now, it was troublesome to say whether or not and the way local weather change affected a selected storm, however more and more, scientists are performing so-called attribution research to quantify these impacts.
A number of preliminary assessments of Hurricane Helene have been launched, connecting the “catastrophic impacts” of the hurricane to climate change. Every report has discovered that local weather change elevated the storm’s whole rainfall, and of the 2 experiences that assessed wind speeds, each discovered that local weather change made the hurricane extra intense. An early report on Hurricane Milton equally indicated that local weather change made the hurricane wetter and windier.
Editor’s be aware: FactCheck.org doesn’t settle for promoting. We depend on grants and particular person donations from individuals such as you. Please contemplate a donation. Bank card donations could also be made via our “Donate” page. In case you want to provide by test, ship to: FactCheck.org, Annenberg Public Coverage Middle, 202 S. thirty sixth St., Philadelphia, PA 19104.
Sources
“Hurricane Helene Makes Landfall in Florida.” NOAA web site. 27 Sep 2024.
“Hurricane Milton Crosses Florida.” NASA web site. Entry 11 Oct 2024.
Berger, Ilana and Chloe Simon. “As Hurricane Milton Grows, so Do Conspiracy Theories Falsely Attributing Hurricanes to Weather Manipulation.” Media Issues for America. 9 Oct 2024.
Earl Allen. “Here’s the link, look for yourself …” Fb. 4 Oct 2024.
Joel & Christine Williams (@homemaderevival). “A hurricane as weather warfare. If you want to argue with me I’m happy to bury you in patents, gov contracts and tax dollars. You are looking at one of the most horrific events ever perpetrated by our government on its own people …” Instagram. 2 Oct 2024.
Grant Cardone (@GrantCardone). “I grew up on the Gulf of Mexico. Been watching storms since I was a young boy. I have NEVER seen a storm start here and go east. Do you think Gov’t is using technology to manipulate weather patterns & storms?” X. 6 Oct 2024.
Ben Swann (@benswann_). “Is weather modification causing more powerful storms? Hurricane Milton is said to be a perfect storm. Why are we seeing stronger, more powerful storms? Is this the result of government lasers and cloud seeding? #ExtremeWeather #HurricaneMilton #NaturalDisasters.” Instagram. 10 Oct 2024.
Stew Peters (@realstewpeters). “Hurricane Milton is targeted geo-engineered storm being used as a weapon. …” X. 7 Oct 2024.
Marjorie Taylor Greene (@mtgreenee). “Yes they can control the weather. It’s ridiculous for anyone to lie and say it can’t be done.” X. 3 Oct 2024.
Marjorie Taylor Greene (@mtgreenee). “This is a map of hurricane affected areas with an overlay of electoral map by political party shows how hurricane devastation could affect the election.” X. 3 Oct 2024.
“Flood of Hurricane Myths Seen by Millions.” NewsGuard’s Actuality Test. 9 Oct 2024.
Marjorie Taylor Greene (@mtgreenee). “[no text].” X. 7 Oct 2024.
Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene (@RepMTG). “Yes they can control the weather. Here is Obama’s CIA Director John Brennan talking about it. Anyone who says they don’t, or makes fun of this, is lying to you. By the way, the people know it and hate all of you who try to cover it up.” X. 5 Oct 2024.
Marjorie Taylor Greene (@mtgreenee). “Lasers.. CBS, 9 years ago, talked about lasers controlling the weather.” X. 5 Oct 2024.
Steck, Em and Andrew Kaczynski. “Marjorie Taylor Greene’s History of Dangerous Conspiracy Theories and Comments | CNN Politics.” CNN. 4 Feb 2021.
Chait, Jonathan. “Marjorie Taylor Greene Blamed Wildfires on Secret Jewish Space Laser.” Intelligencer. 28 Jan 2021.
Kiely, Eugene. “What Vice President Harris Said — And Didn’t Say — About Hurricane Relief.” FactCheck.org. 3 Oct 2024.
Friedrich, Katja. Emails to FactCheck.org. 8 and 9 Oct 2024.
Shear, Michael D. “Biden Accuses Trump of ‘Outright Lies’ About Hurricane Response.” The New York Occasions. 9 Oct 2024.
Marjorie Taylor Greene (@mtgreenee). “Yeah it’s the cow farts. Duh.” X. 7 Oct 2024.
Shannon Suttles (@shannonsuttles_). “… There are many weather manipulation patents. It is NOT climate change! It is NOT just you! Listen to your gut and PRAY!” Threads. 9 Oct 2024.
Geinel Rodriguez (@ggrose85). “… Pray for North Carolina and Tennessee!!!! And all the ones affected by the Weather modification crimes hiding behind the label of Climate Change!!!” Instagram. 6 Oct 2024.
“Global Assessment: Urgent steps must be taken to reduce methane emissions this decade.” UN Setting Program press launch. 6 Might 2021.
“Which is a bigger methane source: cow belching or cow flatulence?” NASA web site. Accessed 11 Oct 2024.
Knutson, Tom. Emails to FactCheck.org. 9 and 11 Oct 2024.
Mahdawi, Arwa. “Wild Conspiracies about the Weather Are Spreading Online. The Media Can Help.” The Guardian.10 Oct 2024.
Rachel Barker Brown (@rachel_brown7). “Currently, that Helene was manipulated through cloud seeding and other means to cause mass destruction.” Threads. 6 Oct 2024.
TeddyDiesel (@teddydindustries). “Cloud seeding and weather modification is 100% real. They don’t even try to hide it anymore.” Instagram. 3 Oct 2024.
Marjorie Taylor Greene (@mtgreenee). “‘Marjorie Taylor Greene was right. Yes, scientists do control the weather.’” X. 8 Oct 2024.
Morgan Religion (@morganfaithofficial). “Look up cloud seeding… may be a huge reach but I’m thinking these hurricanes aren’t getting this strong by themselves….” Threads. 6 Oct 2024.
Harvey, Chelsea and E&E Information. “Eight States Are Seeding Clouds to Overcome Megadrought.” Scientific American. 16 Mar 2021.
Katwala, Amit. “Humans Are Racing to Control the Weather—Using Drones, Lasers, and Salt.” Wired. 30 Jul 2024.
French, Jeffrey R. et al. “Precipitation Formation from Orographic Cloud Seeding.” Proceedings of the Nationwide Academy of Sciences. 22 Jan 2018.
Chen, Angus. “Does cloud seeding really work? An experiment above Idaho suggests humans can turbocharge snowfall.” Science. 22 Jan 2028.
Meg (@meggy2112). “Do the research and you’ll hopefully start to wake up. HAARP. Bouvet Island. Project Cirrus. Project stormfury. We had technology in the 1940s to attempt weather modification. I can’t fathom the technology we have now.” Threads. 7 Oct 2024.
Castronuova, Cara. “Marjorie Taylor Greene’s Weather Manipulation Claims Backed by Science — Must Read Deep Dive into History of Weather Manipulation — Shocking Facts Revealed!” Gateway Pundit. 8 Oct 2024.
“Hurricanes Frequently Asked Questions.” NOAA web site. Up to date 1 Jun 2023.
Cummins, Eleanor. “With Operation Popeye, the U.S. Government Made Weather an Instrument of War.” Widespread Science. 20 Mar 2018.
The VanMan Firm (@the_vanman_company). “Say the weather can be controlled you are looked at as nuts…” Instagram. 3 Oct 2024.
Tuquero, Loreben. “Weather Modification Did Not Make Hurricane Helene.” PolitiFact. 27 Sep 2024.
LaCapria, Kim. “Did Physicist Michio Kaku Say HAARP Caused Irma and Harvey?” Snopes. 11 Sep 2017.
Kasparian, Jérôme. Dialog with FactCheck.org. 10 Oct 2024.
Henin, S. et al. “Field Measurements Suggest the Mechanism of Laser-Assisted Water Condensation.” Nature Communications. 30 Aug 2011.
Houard, Aurélien et al. “Laser-Guided Lightning.” Nature Photonics. 16 Jan 2023.
I Am Awake. “NOTHING TO SEE HERE…… and wouldn’t ya believe this is just the tip of the iceberg with much many need to wake up about??? Things are not as they seem……” Fb. 4 Oct 2024.
Wade, Natalie. “Posts falsely blame HAARP research project for Hurricane Helene.” AFP Truth Test. 1 Oct 2024.
“FAQ.” HAARP web site. Accessed 11 Oct 2024.
“How do scientists know climate change is happening?” FactCheck.org. 26 Mar 2024.
Knutson, Tom. “Global Warming and Hurricanes.” NOAA web site.
Landsea, Chris and Tom Knutson. “Can we expect Atlantic hurricanes to change over the coming century due to global warming?” Local weather.gov. 6 Jun 2022.
Clarke B. et al. “Climate change key driver of catastrophic impacts of Hurricane Helene that devastated both coastal and inland communities.” Imperial Faculty London web site. 9 Oct 2024.
“Heavy precipitation and strong winds in Hurricane Helene mostly strengthened by human-driven climate change.” ClimaMeter. 30 Sep 2024.
Risser, Mark et al. “Climate change may have caused as much as 50% more rainfall during Hurricane Helene in some parts of Georgia and the Carolinas.” Accessed 11 Oct 2024.
“Yet another hurricane wetter, windier and more destructive because of climate change.” World Climate Attribution. 11 Oct 2024.
